Need a quick gift? Invited to a party and all your fruitcake is gone? Are your relatives used to raiding your cookie jar?
Whatever the reason, we have goodies this season!
Stop in anytime we’re open [12/4-12/24] to peruse our lobby full of sweet treats and gifts, packaged to give and enjoy!
Holiday orders can be placed at any time.
Payment options: cash or check.
Bakery address: N6947 Jennifer Drive Plymouth WI 53073
Any menu item with a * after contains nuts.
Due to the volume of orders in December, our normal business hours change and we are ONLY able to accommodate pick up appointments during the calendar hours specified. *HOURS ARE LISTED AT THE END OF THIS MENU *
~ Cookies can be ordered as an assortment or individual flavors; i.e. 1 dozen ‘gingerbread trees’. *If you would like to request specific flavors, they must be ordered by the dozen. * Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.
~ You can place a cookie order or just stop in our lobby & pick up one of our gift packaged cookie assortment boxes:
Petite~ 1/2 dozen assorted box, perfect for a simple gift or just a little taste. $5
Deluxe~1.5 dozen assorted box, with a couple of extras of course! $15
Grand~ 2.5 dozen assorted box, a generous amount of cookies, the ultimate gift! $24
~Buy any 10 dozen cookies from This year’s cookie list: get the 11th free PLUS receive a 10% coupon good for your next order!
~Cookies with a * contain nuts. Nut free assortment boxes may be ordered ahead of time. Please request when placing your order.
This year’s cookie list:
Lemon Sandwich Cremes
Chocolate Mint Thumbprints
Caramel Cashew *
Pistachio dipped Rounds*
Hot cocoa cremes
White Choc. Cranberry Macadamia Nut *
Hazelnut Crescents *
Rum praline buttons *
Cardamom Honey Snowflakes
Ho ho’s sugar crinkles
Swedish spice delights
Minty swirly spirals
Raspberry Linzer *
Classic Almond Spritz
Dusted Pecan Sandies*
White Chocolate Holiday Trees
SIGNATURE SUGAR COOKIE CUTOUTS
This year’s collection is a lovely variety of classic, festive & colorful designs. Minimum order 1 dozen, $18. *Gluten free cutouts also available, minimum order 2 dozen, $40.
DIY COOKIE BOX
Thinking of spending some time with your kids or grandkids decorating cutout cookies this season?? What if you didn’t have to bake the cutouts or gather the decorating supplies! Bettersweet has put together the solution in our annual classic sugar cookie kits. This DIY box comes with a generous baker’s dozen of freshly baked cutout cookies, our signature butter frosting, and several small containers of festive sprinkle & sugar decorating choices. Minimum order 1 kit, $15.
Have a lot of sprinkles but just short on time? You can order our signature cutout cookies, without the frosting & décor. Essentially, half of the DIY kit. Minimum order 1 dozen cookies, $10.
ST. NICK ‘SANTA’ COOKIES
We transform our sugar cookies into larger circles and frost them into a whimsical santa face. Incredibly cute and perfect for any stocking or little gift! No minimum order, $2.50 per cookie.
Also known as our ‘plain jane’ macaroons, you’ll love our sweet delicate coconut treats.
Minimum order 1.5 dozen box, $12.
EARL GREY & FRIENDS
The absolute perfect trio of tea & citrus inspired shortbreads; earl grey, cranberry orange and English breakfast. Unique, yes, but you need to try them! Minimum order 1 dozen box, $8.
The original boys & girls of Christmas town! Approximately 7×5, these old fashioned gingerbread cookies are available in either a simple boy or girl design. Wrapped and ribboned and packaged on a sturdy board… a truly sweet gift. No minimum order, $4 each.
CHOCOLATE DIPPED SAMMIES
An absolute best seller last year! Our nearly-everyone-famous sammie sandwich cookies are half dipped in rich chocolate, drizzled with a little more chocolate and finished with a touch of edible gold. Minimum order 1 dozen box, $12.
ALMOND CHERRY DIAMONDS
Returning from the cookie vault, these almond shortbread sandwich cookies are filled with bright cherry jam. A festive touch to any cookie plate! Minimum order 1 baker’s dozen box, $12. *
Hand rolled truffles: Smooth, rich and velvety. Our petite 2 piece box is absolutely a chocolate lover’s dream, as well as a perfect little treat! Choose EITHER our
Christmas Eve box: Dark Chocolate & Salted Caramel $3.25/pc. box
Christmas Day box: Grand Mariner [orange] & Coffee $3.25/pc. box
Carole’s Grasshopper Squares: A favorite from our first Christmas season. A rich chocolate base is layered with a delicious minty cream and then enrobed in decadent chocolate ganache. Available as a 6 piece box, $22 or a 1 piece box, $3.75. Renamed for a beloved family member who gave them to everyone on her list 🙂
Peanut Butter Balls: Who doesn’t remember sneaking these in their childhood? Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.
Traditional Rum Rounds: These decadent candies will be a nostalgic addition to your holiday celebration. Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.
Peppermint Stripe Cocoa Squares: New this year! A rich brownie is frosted with a peppermint swirl & dusted with edible sparkle. Minimum order 8 piece box, $9.
Minimum order 1/2 dozen per flavor, $13
All cupcakes will be decorated with cute holiday sugars and complementing colored sugars.
~ Chocolate w/ cookies n’ crème filling & cookies n’ crème frosting [topped with a handcrafted sammie cookie!]
~ Vanilla bean w/ eggnog crème filling & spiced bourbon butter frosting
~ Chocolate mint w/ mint chip crème filling & chocolate ganche frosting
~ French vanilla white chocolate w/ raspberry cheesecake crème filling & signature butter frosting
~ Gingerbread spice w/ salted caramel vanilla crème & cinnamon cream cheese frosting
~ Red & green vanilla sprinkle w/ vanilla marshmallow crème filling & peppermint butter frosting
New this year! All of our Christmas cakes are available as a single layer 8” cake [serves 6-8] OR a tall 8” cake [serves 12-14]
BLACK FOREST ~ Your celebration centerpiece! This light chocolate cake is filled with a specialty cherry whipped crème and our own slow simmered cherry compote. Finished with chocolate curls and a touch of fudge. 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38.
SANTA CLAUS ~cocoa-mint cake filled with velvety fudge & then frosted with a minty butter cream to image Kris Kringle himself. 8” single heart, $20 or 8? tall heart, $38.
FRESH SNOWFLAKE ~how does a simple triple vanilla cake sound? Delightful indeed. Our french vanilla cake is filled with signature vanilla crème and our bsb’s butter frosting. This frosty white cake is decorated with a icy blue snowflake over the entire top. Finished with edible sparkle and certain to catch your eye. 8” single, $18 or 8? tall, $34.
CHRISTMAS MORNING ~ As bakers, we often get asked our favorite cake flavors. This creation has always been in our top five, and this year we’re sharing it with you! A lovely classic vanilla cake is filled with fresh orange curd crème, topped with our signature chocolate ganache and finished with sliced almonds around the edges. A dusting of dark chocolate cocoa powder and touch of lavish edible gold glitter. * 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38. *
THE DOLLY~ One of the decorator’s favorites! The cake itself is a soft balance of vanilla bean, fresh orange and hints of cranberry. Filled then with a new cranberry orange compote crème and a thin layer of house made orange curd, this stunning centerpiece will leave you speechless! 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38.
ALISON’S DREAM~ A lovely coconut cake filled with almond paste sweet crème, frosted with our signature butter cream and covered with both elegant coconut shavings and slivered almonds. 8” single, $18 or 8? tall, $34. *
*SPECIALTY CHRISTMAS TREATS*
LEMON RICOTTA LOAF ~ Looking for something light and refreshing? You will find this fresh creation to be a delightful combination of a classic pound cake, lemon flavor, and a lightly sweetened glaze. Loaf cake serves 6-8 guests, $10.
BUCHE DE NOEL~ This fabulous French tradition can be a centerpiece at your celebration. A golden butter sponge cake is filled with EITHER classic chocolate mousse or mocha hazelnut mousse. Rolled into a log with fresh buttercream icing, flaked chocolate and of course, festive edible decorations to make your holiday spirit swoon. $40.
Handcrafted hot cocoa mix:
$7.50/pint. $3.75/half pint. $13/set of 3 half pints [one of each flavor].
Add a bag of soft, white mini marshmallows, $1/bag.
Spiced Nuts: We use a base of real butter, natural coconut or maple sugar and spice to create our tasty combinations in a healthier version of these holiday classics.
Minimum order 1/2 pound, $8. *
~Rosemary Maple Pecans
~Sea Salted Chai Deluxe Mixed Nuts
~Orange Cinnamon Almonds new this year!
*HOLIDAY TEA BREADS*
Minimum order: 1 loaf per flavor, $6.75 or 2 mini loaves per flavor, $7
Eggnog Holiday Pecan *
Cinnamon Apple Streusel
Almond Cherry Poppy Seed*
Triple Chocolate Chip
All granola flavors can be created gluten free with a 2 pound minimum [same flavor].
Honey Almond~ A requested favorite that had to be added again this year. Oat flakes, almonds, hazelnuts, honey, coconut sugar, coconut oil, sea salt, vanilla & almond flavorings. Minimum order 1 pound, $8. *
High Five~ The original BSB granola. Oat flakes, wheat flakes, spelt flakes, rye flakes, raw almonds, sunflower seeds, ground flax, honey, agave syrup, olive oil, dried cranberries, dried cherries, cinnamon, & spices. Minimum order 1 pound, $7.50. *
Good Morning~ The seasonal granola! Oat flakes, unsweetened coconut, raw almonds, raw pecans, dried apricots, dried cherries, crystallized ginger, orange zest, coconut milk, honey, sea salt, vanilla & spices. Minimum order 1 pound, $8. *
*CUSTOM GIFT BOXES*
Perfect for office parties, neighbor goodwill, teacher thank you’s, the foodie in your family or the “I don’t know what to get this person” gift. Built a box with your own selections and we’ll make it look nice! $25 per box.
Here’s what we’ll put in the box:
2 mini loaves tea bread [you pick the flavors]
1 half pint jar of hot cocoa [you pick the flavor]
1 bag of mini marshmallows
1 two piece box of traditional rum balls
1 two piece box of hand rolled truffles [you pick the flavor]
1 petite [1/2 dozen] box of assorted cookies
We’ll add some festive paper shred and extra candies & wrap the whole box up with ribbon and love.
*BAKERS IN TRAINING*
Cake Pop Truffles~ Flavors may change weekly based upon creative desire. Gift packaged and quite delicious, errr… addictive! Minimum order box of 8, $10.
M’s Eclairs~ A now famous recipe, these oversized chocolate eclairs are so good, you’ll eat them all before dinner. Minimum order 1 dozen, $25.
Memorized M &M Cookies~ He really does have the recipie down pat in this fantastic version of a classic. Minimum order 6 cookies, $3.50.
Reindeer Snack Mix~ A colorful blend of mini animal crackers, white frosted pretzels, chocolate dots, peppermint pretzel balls.. Just to name a few. Minimum order 1 festive bag, $2.50.
Please read through our calendar of available pick up days and times. Remember from 12/4-12/24, our lobby tables will also be stocked with sweet treats and extra goodies!
SUNDAY, 12/1, MONDAY, 12/2 & TUESDAY, 12/3: CLOSED
WEDNESDAY 12/4: 12-7 PM
THURSDAY, 12/5: 12-7 PM
FRIDAY, 12/6: 12-7 PM
SATURDAY, 12/7: 9-3 PM
SUNDAY, 12/8 & MONDAY, 12/9: CLOSED
TUESDAY, 12/10: 12-7 PM
WEDNESDAY, 12/11: 12-7 PM
THURSDAY, 12/12: 12-7 PM
FRIDAY, 12/13: 9-7 PM
SATURDAY, 12/14: 9-3 PM
SUNDAY, 12/15 & MONDAY, 12/16: CLOSED
TUESDAY, 12/17: 12-7 PM
WEDNESDAY, 12/18: 9-7 PM
THURSDAY, 12/19: 9-7 PM
FRIDAY, 12/20: 9-7 PM
SATURDAY, 12/21: 9-7 PM
SUNDAY, 12/22: 1-7 PM, SPECIAL HOURS!
MONDAY, 12/23: 9-7 PM
TUESDAY, 12/24: 8-11 AM [CHRISTMAS EVE]
WEDNESDAY , 12/25: CLOSED [CHRISTMAS DAY]
THURSDAY 12/26: CLOSED
FRIDAY, 12/7: 1-6 PM
SATURDAY, 12/28: 9-3 PM
SUNDAY, 12/29, MONDAY, 12/30 & TUESDAY 12/31: CLOSED
JANUARY HOURS: Note: Bettersweet will be closed for our annual winter break as listed below.
WEDNESDAY 1/1 & THURSDAY 1/2: CLOSED
FRIDAY, 1/3: 12-6 PM
SATURDAY, 1/4: 9-3 PM
SUNDAY, 1/5–THURSDAY, 1/16: CLOSED
FRIDAY, 1/17: 9-6 PM
SATURDAY, 1/18: BY APPOINTMENT
SUNDAY, 1/19-TUESDAY, 1/21: CLOSED
WEDNESDAY, 1/22: 9-6 PM
THURSDAY, 1/23: 9- 6 PM
FRIDAY, 1/24: 9-6 PM
SATURDAY, 1/25: BY APPOINTMENT
SUNDAY, 1/26-TUESDAY, 1/28: CLOSED
WEDNESDAY, 1/29: 9-6 PM
THURSDAY, 1/30: 9- 6 PM
FRIDAY, 1/31: 9-6 PM