Current Pick Up Hours: Thursdays 12-6 pm, Fridays 12-6 pm & select Saturdays depending on availability. 

Cake flavors 

Vanilla inspired:

french vanilla vanilla bean white chocolate
rainbow sprinkle vanilla poppy seed vanilla chocolate chip

Chocolate inspired:

classic chocolate milk chocolate marble [choc. & van.]

Fruit inspired: 

fresh lemon fresh orange coconut
lemon poppy seed    

Coffee shop inspired:

spice almond [nut free] caramel
cognac almond poppy seed irish cream
coffee espresso amaretto  

_____________________________________________________________

All of our fillings are crème based, to hold the moisture in our cake and cupcake creations as well as offer you unending flavor combination possibilities.  ALL cakes and cupcakes we create are filled.  

Filling flavors:

Vanilla inspired:

signature vanilla crème cheesecake crème marshmallow crème

Coffee shop inspired:

caramel crème cappuccino crème pecan crème [nut free]
mint crème irish crème  

Gourmet filling flavors:

Chocolate inspired:

crushed white chocolate crème crushed chocolate crème  double chocolate fudge crème
cookies n’ cream crème mint chocolate chip  

Fruit inspired:

raspberry compote crème lemon curd crème  orange curd crème
blueberry compote crème mixed berry [raspberry, blackberry & blueberry] compote crème pineapple rum crème

Coffee shop inspired:

salted caramel crème English toffee crème almond paste crème [contains nuts] 
chocolate raspberry cappuccino crème peanut butter crème [contains nuts]  

 _____________________________________________________________

Frosting flavors

signature butter  *  cream cheese  *  vanilla bean butter *

almond butter [nut free] * cinnamon butter * mocha butter

cocoa butter  *   bourbon butter  *  

_____________________________________________________________

Cake Size Options: Please denote the size desired when ordering.  Some custom decoration requests will be charged an additional fee, which is reflected in the price range listed. 

  • SHORT is one cake, cut and filled, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor, and one frosting flavor.  
  • TALL is two cakes, the same size, both cut and filled, meaning you can chose two cake flavors, two filling flavors and one cake frosting flavor. 

6” short round [serves 3-4]. $12-14.  For gourmet filling, add $1.  * Marble cake flavor not available in 6″ short size. 

6” tall round [serves 6-8]. $24-26. For gourmet filling, add $2.  * Marble cake flavor not available in 6″ tall size. 

8” short round [serves 4-6]. $20-22.  For gourmet filling, add $2. * Marble cake flavor not available in 8″ short size. 

8” tall round [serves 12-14]. $34-36. For gourmet filling, add $4 

10” short round [serves 10-12]. $26-28.  For gourmet filling, add $4. 

10” tall round [serves 18-24]. $48-50. For gourmet filling, add $6. 

12” short [serves 20-26 ]. $34-36.  For gourmet filling, add $4. 

12” tall round [serves 28-38]. $62-64. For gourmet filling, add $8. 

Sheet Cake Size Options: Our sheet cakes are all single layer, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor and one frosting flavor.  

9×13 single layer sheet cake [serves 20-24].  $40-42.  For gourmet filling, add $6. 

11×15 single layer sheet cake [serves 26-30].  $50-52.  For gourmet filling, add $8. 

12×18 single layer sheet cake [serves 34-40].  $64-66.  For gourmet filling, add $10. 

Cupcake Quantity OptionsPlease denote the size and quantity desired when ordering.

1 dozen regular size. $26.  Minimum order 1 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole dozen, but you can choose do have 1/2 of the dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other 1/2 a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet filling, add $1-2 per dozen. Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor. 

2 dozen mini size. $26.  Minimum order 2 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole 2 dozen, but you can choose do have 1 dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other dozen a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet filling, add $1-2 per dozen. Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor. 

______________________________________________________________

Signature CakesThe cakes below are true Bettersweet creations.  They are created the same each time we make them, so please understand they can not be altered; ie. changing out a filling flavor or leaving out the nuts.  They also come with a pre-set decoration, so if you are looking to have a custom design, you may want to build your own cake combination.

The Best Ever Carrot Cake 

This recipe has been perfected over time with distinctive fillings and cream cheese frosting. It’s been said, this cake will change your life!  *contains coconut and walnuts.  Available in 8″ tall- $48, 10″ tall- $75, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $32 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $32.  

Uncle Bob’s Red Velvet 

Overflowing with color and flavor, this light cocoa cake is layered with specialty fillings including our semi-sweet crème, hints of sugared ground almonds and rich European chocolate garnishing. Simply stunning.  *contains almonds.  Available in 8″ tall- $42, 10″ tall-$65, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $30 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $30.  

Ma’s Almond Joy 

This coconut & almond flavored vanilla cake is baked with 3 types of crushed chocolate and generously filled with our signature vanilla crème. Frosted with nothing better than our BSB butter and flaked coconut.  *contains coconut and almonds.  Available as a 8″ tall- $42, 10″ tall- $65, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $30 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $30.  

**the signature cake section is still under construction.  please contact us with questions or check back in the near future.  thank you! **