Cake & Cupcake Menu

Thanks for visiting! Below you will find our cake and cupcake options.   After looking things over, please don’t hesitate to call or email with any questions you might have regarding your order.

Please note:

~ Some of our previous flavors have been discontinued due to issues with ingredient availability.  We have added some new flavors, so you might just find a new favorite.

~ We have adjusted some of our minimum order requirements and size options.  Our hope is to offer you more flexibility in ordering, especially for smaller celebrations.

~ Ordering details are given at the bottom of this page.

~ If you are planning your wedding, please know we will discuss the pricing and size options during our consultation appointment.  Details on this page are not reflective for wedding clients.  

Cake Size Options: Please denote the size desired when ordering.  Some custom decoration requests will be charged an additional fee, which is reflected in the price range listed. 

  • Single layer is one cake, cut and filled, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor, and one frosting flavor.  Double layer is two cakes, the same size, both cut and filled, meaning for 10″, 12″ and 14″ sizes you can chose two cake flavors, two filling flavors and one cake frosting flavor.  6″ and 8″ double layer cakes follow the same choice options as single layer cakes.  Please note, marble cake flavor is NOT AVAILABLE in 6″ or 8″ size, single or double layer.

6” single layer round [serves 3-4]. $12-14.  For gourmet filling, add $1.  

6” double layer round [serves 6-8]. $24-26. For gourmet filling, add $2.  

8” single layer round [serves 4-6]. $20-22.  For gourmet filling, add $2. 

8” double layer round [serves 12-14]. $34-36. For gourmet filling, add $4 

10” single layer round [serves 10-12]. $26-28.  For gourmet filling, add $4. 

10” double layer round [serves 18-24]. $48-50. For gourmet filling, add $6. 

12” single layer round [serves 20-26 ]. $34-36.  For gourmet filling, add $4. 

12” double layer round [serves 28-38]. $62-64. For gourmet filling, add $8. 

14” single layer round [serves 36-46 ]. $46-48.  For gourmet filling, add $6. 

14” double layer round [serves 48-58]. $88-90. For gourmet filling, add $10. 

 

Sheet Cake Size Options: Our sheet cakes are all single layer, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor and one frosting flavor.  

9×13 single layer sheet cake [serves 20-24].  $40-42.  For gourmet filling, add $6. 

11×15 single layer sheet cake [serves 26-30].  $50-52.  For gourmet filling, add $8. 

12×18 single layer sheet cake [serves 43-40].  $64-66.  For gourmet filling, add $10. 

 

Tiered Cake Size Options: Information coming soon!  Please check back or inquire when ordering.

 

Cupcake Quantity Options: Please denote the size and quantity desired when ordering.

1 dozen regular size. $26.  Minimum order 1 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole dozen, but you can choose do have 1/2 of the dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other 1/2 a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet filling, add $1-2. 

2 dozen mini size. $26.  Minimum order 2 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole 2 dozen, but you can choose do have 1 dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other dozen a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet filling, add $1-2. 

____________________________________________________________________________________

Cake Flavor Options:

French Vanilla

White Chocolate

Classic Chocolate

Milk Chocolate

Rainbow Sprinkle

Marble [choc & van]

Fresh Lemon

Fresh Orange

Vanilla Bean

Coffee Espresso

Caramel

Almond [nut free]

Vanilla Poppy Seed

Lemon Poppy Seed

Almond Poppy Seed

Spice

Amaretto

Cognac

     

Marble is NOT AVAILABLE for 6″ or 8″ cake sizes or for cupcake orders.

 

Cake Filling Options: All of our fillings are crème based, to hold the moisture in our cake and cupcake creations, and ALL cakes and cupcakes we create are filled.

Signature Vanilla  Caramel  Mint 
Cheesecake  Cappuccino  Irish Cream
Caramel  Choc. Hazelnut [nuts] Marshmallow
Pecan [nut free]    

Gourmet Filling Options:  [previously known as specialty filling flavors]

Crushed White Chocolate

Crushed Chocolate

Raspberry Compote 

Blueberry Compote 

Mint Chip

Peanut Butter [nuts]

Double Chocolate Fudge

Mixed Berry Compote [blueberry, raspberry, blackberry]

Chocolate Raspberry Cappuccino

Cookies n’ Cream

 

Lemon Curd

Orange Curd

English Toffee

 

     

Cake Frosting Options:

Signature Butter

Cream Cheese

Cinnamon Butter

Cocoa Butter

Vanilla Bean Butter

Bourbon Butter

Mocha Butter

Almond Butter

 

     

Chocolate ganache is available for an additional charge.  Please inquire when placing your order.

__________________________________________________________________________________

Ordering Details:

* Please email us or call 920/893.0617 to place your order.  All orders will be confirmed via email or phone.

* Our lobby is currently closed! Please read about our curbside pick up procedure here: bettersweetbakery.com

* Pick up hours are Thursdays 12-6 pm, Fridays 12-6 pm & Saturdays 10-2 pm. 

* Order deadlines:       

For Thursday pick up, please place by Tuesday at noon. 

For Friday pick up, please place by Wednesday at noon.

For Saturday pick up, please place by Thursday at noon.

 

                                                                                                                                                      

* Checks payable to Bettersweet Bakery or cash will be accepted at the time of pickup.

* Custom decoration and an order total will be given when your order is confirmed.