Build your own decorated cake.
The next time you need a special occasion cake consider Bettersweet’s incredible possibilities. As you see below, the combinations of cake flavor, filling type and frosting are nearly endless, and if overwhelmed with choices, take a look over our suggested combinations page. Each cake is baked fresh for your order and artistically decorated, complementing the purpose of your celebration.
For pricing and serving size charts, please view our pricing page. Depending on how many guests you plan on serving, there may be more than one option in cake shape or size. We can help you determine the best fit for your occasion.
Our prices are based on your selection of the following: 1-2 cake flavors, 1-2 filling flavors per cake, and 1 frosting type.
Please call for pricing on larger sizes.
1. Choose 1-2 cake flavors.
A second flavor is only available on 2-layer, 10 in. or larger cakes. Smaller cakes and single-layer cakes allow for one flavor only.
| Classic Cake Flavors | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Almond | Chocolate Cherry | Fresh Lemon | Kaluha |
| Amaretto | Chocolate Mint | Fresh Orange | Marble * |
| Butter Rum | Classic Vanilla | Golden Marble * | Milk Chocolate |
| Butter Vanilla | Coffee | Hazelnut | Milk Chocolate Marble * |
| Caramel | Dark Chocolate | Irish Cream | White Chocolate |
| Cherry | French Vanilla | ||
| * Not available in 6 or 8 inch size | |||
| Specialty Cake Flavors (see price list for additional cost) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Almond Poppy Seed | Chocolate Raspberry | Dulce De Leche [European Caramel] | Vanilla Bean |
| Blueberry Coconut | Chocolate Red Velvet | Fresh Blueberry | Vanilla Chocolate Chip |
| Cherry Chocolate Chip | Coconut | Fresh Lime | Vanilla Poppy Seed |
| Chocolate Chocolate Chip | Cognac | Lemon Poppy Seed | Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip |
| Orange Chocolate Chip | Raspberry | ||
Stumped on what flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.
Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.
2. Choose up to 2 fillings.
Note: some smaller and single-layer cakes allow for one filling only.
| Classic Filling Flavors | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| BSB's Signature Vanilla Crème | Chocolate Hazelnut Crème | Hazelnut Cappuccino Crème | Pecan Crème |
| Butterscotch Crème | Chocolate Raspberry Cappuccino Crème | Hazelnut Crème | Pumpkin Spice Cappuccino Crème |
| Cappuccino Crème | Coffee Crème | Malted Milk Crème | Raspberry [layered with vanilla crème] * |
| Caramel Cappuccino Crème | Cotton Candy Crème | Mango Crème | Root Beer Crème |
| Caramel Crème | Creamy Chai Crème | Maple Crème | Rum & Coke |
| Cheesecake Crème | Dark Hot Chocolate Crème | Marshmallow Crème | Tropical Punch Crème |
| Banana Creme | Eggnog Crème | Mint Crème | Watermelon Crème |
| Banana Rum Creme | English Toffee Crème | Peaches & Crème | White Chocolate Cappuccino Crème |
| Chocolate Crème | Eclair | ||
| * Contains real fruit pieces or zest | |||
| Specialty Filling Flavors (see price list for additional cost) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Almond Paste Crème | Fresh Strawberry Crème * | Mint Chocolate Chip Crème | Pineapple Rum * |
| Apricot Crème * | Fudge | Orange Crème * | Pistachio Crème |
| Blueberry Compote Crème * | Fudge Crème | Orange Curd Crème | Salted Caramel Crème |
| Cognac Crème | Lemon Curd Crème | Oreo Crème | Vanilla Bean Crème |
| Crushed Chocolate Crème | Lime Curd Crème | Peanut Butter Crème | White Chocolate Lavender |
| Espresso Crème | Cherry Creme | Cherry Chocolate Chip Creme | |
| * Contains real fruit pieces or zest | |||
Stumped on what filling flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.
Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.
3. Choose a frosting flavor.
Our butter frostings are similar to the commonly known buttercream, made with 100% butter —no exceptions! Smooth, creamy and not too sweet.
| Classic Frosting Flavors | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| BSB's Signature Butter | Almond Butter | Cocoa Butter | Cream Cheese |
| Specialty Frosting Flavors (see price list for additional cost) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Raspberry | Ganache | Oreo Butter | Peanut Butter Butter |
| Sour Cream Chocolate Fudge | Vanilla Bean Butter | ||
Stumped on what flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.
Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.
4. Choose a size (final step).
Are your flavors chosen? Visit our cake sizes and pricing page to choose a cake size.
(When you’re ready with your order, order online with our easy-to-use form.)
