Cakes & Cupcakes

Build your own decorated cake.

The next time you need a special occasion cake consider Bettersweet’s incredible possibilities. As you see below, the combinations of cake flavor, filling type and frosting are nearly endless, and if overwhelmed with choices, take a look over our suggested combinations page. Each cake is baked fresh for your order and artistically decorated, complementing the purpose of your celebration.

For pricing and serving size charts, please view our pricing page. Depending on how many guests you plan on serving, there may be more than one option in cake shape or size. We can help you determine the best fit for your occasion.

Our prices are based on your selection of the following: 1-2 cake flavors, 1-2 filling flavors per cake, and 1 frosting type.

Please call for pricing on multi-tiered cakes or other special event cakes.

1. Choose 1-2 cake flavors.

A second cake flavor is only available on 2-layer, 10 in. or larger cakes. 6″ 2 layer, 8″ two layer, single-layer and sheet cakes allow for one flavor only.

Classic Cake Flavors
Almond **Chocolate, DarkFresh Lemon *Marble #
AmarettoChocolate, MilkFresh Orange *Marble, Golden #
Butter RumChocolate, MintFun-illa-fettiMarble, Milk Chocolate #
Butter VanillaClassic VanillaHazelnut **Raspberry *
CaramelCoffeeIrish CreamStrawberry *
Cherry French VanillaKaluhaWhite Chocolate
# Not available in 6 or 8 inch size
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
* Contains nuts or nut flavoring

Specialty Cake Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
Blackberry Chocolate Chip, ChocolateChocolate RaspberryPoppy Seed, Almond **
Blueberry Chocolate Chip, OrangeCoconutPoppy Seed, Lemon
Caramel Pecan **Chocolate Chip, VanillaCognacPoppy Seed, Vanilla
Chocolate Chip, CherryChocolate Cherry
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nuts or nut flavoring

Stumped on what flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.

Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.

2. Choose up to 2 fillings.

ALL fillings listed below are crème based.  Not only do our fillings give you the ability to create flavorful combinations, but the crème holds the moisture content in our cake and cupcakes.  The end result is never dry, always moist and always delicious!

Note: Single-layer  and sheet cakes allow for one filling only!

Classic Filling Flavors
BSB's Signature Vanilla CrèmeCappuccino - Hazelnut Crème **Coffee CrèmeMalted Milk Crème
Banana CrèmeCappuccino- Pumpkin Spice Crème *Creamy Chai CrèmeMarshmallow Crème
Banana Rum CrèmeCappuccino - White Chocolate CrèmeDark Hot Chocolate CrèmeMint Crème
Butterscotch CrèmeCaramel CrèmeEclair CrèmePecan Crème **
Cappuccino CrèmeCheesecake CrèmeIrish CrèmeRoot Beer Crème
Cappuccino- Chocolate Raspberry Crème *Chocolate CrèmeLemonade Creme Rum & Coke Crème
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nuts or nut flavoring

Specialty Filling Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
Almond Paste Crème **Curd, Lemon Crème *Fresh Strawberry Crème *Pineapple Rum Crème *
Blueberry Compote Crème *Curd, Lime Crème *Fudge CrèmePistachio Crème **
Cherry Crème *Curd, Orange Crème *Mint Chocolate Chip CrèmeRaspberry [layered with vanilla crème] *
Cherry Chocolate Chip CrèmeCrushed Chocolate *CrèmeOreo Crème Salted Caramel Crème
Cognac CrèmeEnglish Toffee Crème Peanut Butter Crème **Summer Berry Crème *
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nuts or nut flavorings

Stumped on what filling flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.

Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.

3. Choose a frosting flavor.

Our butter frostings are similar to the commonly known buttercream, made with 100% butter —no exceptions! Smooth, creamy and not too sweet.

Classic Frosting Flavors
BSB's Signature ButterAlmond ButterCaramel Butter Cinnamon Butter
Cocoa Butter [light brown color]Cream CheeseMocha ButterVanilla Bean Butter

Specialty Frosting Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
GanacheOreo ButterPeanut Butter Butter**

Stumped on what flavor to choose? Take a look at our flavor descriptions.

Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.

4. Choose a size (final step).

Are your flavors chosen? Visit our cake sizes and pricing page to choose a cake size.

(When you’re ready with your order, order online with our easy-to-use form.)