Cakes & Cupcakes

Build your own custom cake.

 

1. Choose a size.

  • All serving sizes are approximate & generous!
  • Range in pricing reflects custom decoration requested.
  • All prices are subject to change without notice and current pricing may not always be reflected immediately on website pages.
  • SIGNATURE CAKES DO NOT FALL UNDER SPECIALTY PRICING.  Please see signature cake pricing here.
  • The below sizing and pricing does not include wedding cakes.  Please contact us to set up a consultation to discuss wedding details.
  • Please contact us for pricing on multi-tiered cakes or other special event cakes.
  • Want to know which cakes others love? Check out our suggested cake combinations.

Round Tall Cakes

SizeServingsPriceFor specialty cake flavors, filings and/or frosting, add:
6 inch6-8$20-22$2-4
8 inch12-14$30-32$4-8
10 inch18-24$44-47$6-12
12 inch28-38$60-64$8-16
14 inch48-58$84-88$10-20
16 inch60-76$108-118$12-24

Square Cakes

SizeServingsPriceFor specialty cake flavors, filings and/or frosting, add:
10 x 1014-18$30-32$2-4
12 x 1220-26$40-44$4-8
14 x 1428-36$58-62$6-12
16 x 1640-52$76-82$8-16

Square Tall Cakes

SizeServingsPriceFor specialty cake flavors, filings and/or frosting, add:
8 x 816-20$37-41$4-8
10 x 1026-32$58-62$6-12
12 x 1238-46$78-82$8-16
14 x 1450-70$108-118$10-20
16 x 1680-100$142-154$12-24

Sheet Cakes

SizeServingsPriceFor specialty cake flavors, filings and/or frosting, add:
9x1320-24$35-39$6-12
11x1526-30$48-52$8-16
12x1834-40$62-66$10-20

2. Choose a cake flavor.

6″ & 8″ tall [round or square] and sheet cakes allow for one cake flavor only.

A second cake flavor is only available for the following cake sizes: 10″, 12″, 14″, or 16″ tall [round or square].

Classic Cake Flavors
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
French VanillaBing Cherry *Coffee
Butter VanillaFresh Lemon *Almond
Vanilla Sprinkle Fresh Orange *Hazelnut
Classic ChocolateStrawberry *Amaretto
Milk Chocolate Butter Rum
Classic Marble #Irish Cream
Milk Chocolate Marble #Drunken Coffee
# Not available in 6 or 8 inch cake size
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest

Specialty Cake Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
Vanilla Chocolate ChipBlueberry *Coconut
Chocolate, Chocolate ChipCherry Chocolate Chip *Cognac
Vanilla Poppy SeedLemon Poppy Seed *Almond Poppy Seed **
Caramel Pecan **
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nut pieces

3. Choose a filling flavor.

ALL fillings listed below are crème based.  Not only do our fillings give you the ability to create flavorful combinations, but the crème holds the moisture content in our cake and cupcakes.  The end result is never dry, always moist and always delicious!

Note: Square [not tall] & sheet cakes allow for one filling only!

Classic Filling Flavors
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
Signature VanillaChocolate Raspberry Cappuccino *Original Cappuccino
CheesecakeCaramel
ChocolateHazelnut
Hot CocoaPecan
Spiced Chai
Irish Cream
Malted Milk
Marshmallow
Mint
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nut pieces

Specialty Filling Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
Crushed ChocolateRaspberry Compote *Salted Caramel
Fudge Blueberry Compote *Peanut Butter **
Mint Chocolate ChipMixed Berry Compote *English Toffee
Cookies 'n CreamBing Cherry Compote *Almond Paste **
Lemon Curd *Pistachio **
Orange Curd *Cognac
Fresh Strawberry *
Pineapple Rum *
* Contains real fruit pieces or zest
** Contains nut pieces

4. Choose a frosting flavor.

Our butter frostings are similar to the commonly known buttercream, made with 100% real butter —no exceptions! Smooth, creamy and not too sweet.

Classic Frosting Flavors
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
Signature ButterLemon ButterAlmond Butter
Vanilla Bean ButterMocha Butter
Cream Cheese
Cinnamon Butter
Cocoa Butter [light brown color]Caramel Butter
Bourbon Butter

Specialty Frosting Flavors (see price list for additional cost)
VANILLA & CHOCOLATE FLAVORSFRUITY FLAVORSCOFFEE SHOP FLAVORS
Ganache [not butter based]Peanut Butter Butter **
Cookies n' Cream Butter
** Contains nut pieces

5. Choose your decoration.

Your cake will be decorated with your requests in mind.  Let us know if your celebration has a theme or if there are specific colors you would like us to work with.

Our decorator’s designs have been described as beautiful, artistic and whimsical.  Some designs and specific requests are just not possible with butter based frosting.  The best thing for you to do is let us know what you are looking for~ we’ll let you know what we can [or cannot] do.

*Due to copy write laws, we are unable to replicate any LOGO, LICENSED CHARACTER or TRADEMARKED IMAGE.  We can work with similar colors and can discuss possible additions such as edible images or figurines.

(When you’re ready with your order, order online with our easy-to-use form.)