Tuesday 11/24 CLOSED & LAST DAY TO PLACE THANKSGIVING ORDERS!  Phone calls and emails will be answered throughout the day on Tuesday.

Wednesday 11/25 Pick ups: 2-7pm

Thursday 11/26 *THANKSGIVING* Pick ups: 8-11am 

Friday 11/27 CLOSED

Saturday 11/28 Pick ups: 9-NOON

Please fill out the following form. Items with an * are required fields. You will receive an email or call to confirm you order within 2–3 business days (if you place your order on a Friday-Monday, you will be receiving confirmation on Tuesday, as BSB is closed on Sundays and Mondays). During this email or call a specific pick up time will be arranged, decoration will be discussed and any other questions will be answered.

In general, orders should be placed at least  a  week [or two] in advance. We will try to accommodate last minute requests, but cannot always guarantee our availability during busy times — especially on weekends and holidays. Because all items are fresh and custom ordered, we limit the amount of work we commit to. This ensures your order is a true Bettersweet creation!

Cash and Checks accepted; payable to Bettersweet Bakery.

Phone orders

To place an order by phone, please call:
(920) 893.0617

Email orders

Send an email with your order or questions to:

Customer Information

Pick-up Date and Time

Note: we are closed on Saturdays starting June 1, 2011. Orders may only be scheduled for pickup on Tuesdays-Fridays.

Bettersweet Bakery Hours

  • Tuesday: 1-6 p.m.
  • Wed-Fri: 9 a.m.-6 p.m.
  • Sat, Sun, Mon: CLOSED

Cake Orders

What type of celebration is the order for? (Birthday, anniversary, graduation, etc...)

Unsure about what flavors go well together? Our signature cakes are the ones we recommend.
Click here for a description of each one.

Color and decoration specifications:

Cupcake and Bakery Orders

Cupcakes and bakery items must be ordered via phone or email. To learn more, please select the item(s) below and we'll follow up with you when we confirm your order.

 I'd like to order cupcakes.

 I'd like to order additional bakery items.

Please briefly describe what you'd like and we'll follow up with you when we confirm your order.