Ready to build your own custom cake or cupcake order?  Before you start looking at flavors and sizes, please keep the following in mind:

~ We are not legally able to recreate any licensed characters, logos or trademarked images.  We can work with coordinating colors and can discuss purchasing edible images or figurines to add to your cake to accomplish you desired theme. 

~ Our flavors and price points are subject to change at any point in time.

~ The size options below are not used to configure wedding cakes.  Please contact us for more information!

~ All flavors followed by an * are available as gluten free.  Details on gluten free options can be found at the bottom of this page.  

PLEASE CHECK OUR CURRENT HOURS AND CUSTOM ORDER AVAILIBILITY PRIOR TO ORDERING HERE:  http://bettersweetbakery.com/news/

Standard flavor menu- Cake flavors 

Vanilla inspired:

french vanilla *

vanilla bean *

white chocolate *

rainbow sprinkle *

vanilla poppy seed *

vanilla chocolate chip *

Chocolate inspired:

classic chocolate *

milk chocolate

marble [choc. & van.]

Fruit inspired: 

fresh lemon *

fresh orange *

coconut *

lemon poppy seed *

orange poppy seed *

 

Coffee shop inspired:

coffee espresso *

almond [nut free] *

caramel *

amaretto *

almond poppy seed *

irish cream *

   

 

_____________________________________________________________

All of our fillings are crème based, to hold the moisture in our cake and cupcake creations as well as offer you unending flavor combination possibilities.  ALL cakes and cupcakes we create are filled.  

Standard flavor menu- Filling flavors:

Vanilla inspired:

signature vanilla crème 

cheesecake crème 

marshmallow crème 

Coffee shop inspired:

caramel crème 

cappuccino crème 

pecan crème 

mint crème 

irish crème 

 

Standard flavor menu- Gourmet filling flavors:

Chocolate inspired:

crushed white chocolate crème 

crushed chocolate crème 

double chocolate fudge crème 

cookies n’ cream crème

mint chocolate chip 

 

Fruit inspired:

raspberry compote crème 

lemon curd crème 

cherry bourbon crème 

blueberry compote crème 

mixed berry [raspberry, blackberry & blueberry] compote crème  

 

Coffee shop inspired:

salted caramel crème

English toffee crème

peanut butter crème *

 

 

 

 _____________________________________________________________

Standard flavor menu- Frosting flavors:

signature butter 

cream cheese 

vanilla bean butter 

almond butter

cocoa butter 

mocha butter 

bourbon butter 

 

 

__________________________________________________________

Cake Size Options: Please denote the size desired when ordering.  Some custom decoration requests will be charged an additional fee. 

  • SHORT is one cake, cut and filled, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor, and one frosting flavor.  
  • TALL is two cakes, the same size, both cut and filled, meaning you can chose two cake flavors, two filling flavors and one cake frosting flavor. 

6” short round [serves 2-3]. $17-19.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $2.  * Marble cake flavor not available in 6″ short size. 

6” tall round [serves 6-8]. $29-31. For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $3.  * Marble cake flavor not available in 6″ tall size. 

8” short round [serves 4-6]. $25-27.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $3. * Marble cake flavor not available in 8″ short size. 

8” tall round [serves 12-14]. $39-41. For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $5 

10” short round [serves 10-12]. $31-33.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $5. 

10” tall round [serves 18-24]. $53-55. For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $7. 

12” short [serves 20-26 ]. $45-47.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $5. 

12” tall round [serves 28-38]. $67-69. For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $9. 

Sheet Cake Size Options: Our sheet cakes are all single layer, meaning you can choose one cake flavor, one filling flavor and one frosting flavor.  

9×13 single layer sheet cake [serves 20-24].  $45-49.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $7. 

11×15 single layer sheet cake [serves 26-30].  $55-59.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $9. 

12×18 single layer sheet cake [serves 34-40].  $69-73.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $11. 

Cupcake Quantity OptionsPlease denote the size and quantity desired when ordering.

1 dozen regular size. $31.  Minimum order 1 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole dozen, but you can choose do have 1/2 of the dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other 1/2 a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $2-3 per dozen. Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor. 

2 dozen mini size. $31.  Minimum order 2 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole 2 dozen, but you can choose do have 1 dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other dozen a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $2-3 per dozen. Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor. 

______________________________________________________________

Signature CakesThe cakes below are true Bettersweet creations.  They are created the same each time we make them, so please understand they can not be altered; ie. changing out a filling flavor or leaving out the nuts.  They also come with a pre-set decoration, so if you are looking to have a custom design, you may want to build your own cake combination.  If you’re looking for a size option not listed below, please contact us to see if it’s available.  

The Best Ever Carrot  

This recipe has been perfected over time with distinctive fillings and cream cheese frosting. It’s been said, this cake will change your life!  *contains coconut and walnuts.  Available in 8″ tall- $53, 10″ tall- $83, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $39 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $39.  

Uncle Bob’s Red Velvet 

Overflowing with color and flavor, this light cocoa cake is layered with specialty fillings including our semi-sweet crème, hints of sugared ground almonds and rich European chocolate garnishing. Simply stunning.  *contains almonds.  Available in 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall-$73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35.  

Ma’s Almond Joy 

This coconut & almond flavored vanilla cake is baked with 3 types of crushed chocolate and generously filled with our signature vanilla crème. Frosted with nothing better than our BSB butter and flaked coconut.  *contains coconut and almonds.  Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35.  

PB & Chocolate Nonsense 

This one is for the serious connoisseur.  Peanut butter chocolate chip cake is sent over the top with our crunchy peanut butter creme filling and frosted with our cocoa butter.  Warning:  if eaten while at work, all productivity will immediately halt.  Trust us, we’ve seen it. *contains peanuts.  Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35.  

Good AM  

A chocolate & coffee layer cake is filled with both espresso flecked creme & semi sweet vanilla custard.  A light layer of mocha butter is then completely covered in dark chocolate ganache.  Finished with a trio of chocolate covered espresso beans and a dusting of cocoa powder.  Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35. 

Caramel Layer

This one is a true creation for sweet tooth’s:  golden butter cake is filled with semisweet vanilla custard, caramel drizzle and chocolate fudge.  Both signature butter and cocoa butter frostings cover this treat.  Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35. 

Curt’s ‘Very Chocolate, Very Stout’

This deep chocolate cake partners with the bold, dark flavor of Guinness to create a culinary masterpiece.  A not to thin-not to thick layer of ganache finishes this decadent dessert.  Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35. 

German Chocolate

Our version of this southern classic layers chocolate coconut cake and pecan creme and a light caramel drizzle.  Finished off with the sweet coconut pecan chocolate frosting you’ll recognize.  Lastly, pecans and rich caramel sauce adorn the cake top.  *contains pecans. Available as a 8″ tall- $47, 10″ tall- $73, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $35 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $35. 

Razmon Delight

Our newest creation!  Raspberry flecked vanilla cake is filled with a lemon curd mascarpone creme and frosted with raspberry cream cheese frosting.  Soft pinks and pale yellow make this cake as pretty as it is refreshing. Available in 8″ tall- $53 10″ tall- $83, 1 dozen regular size cupcakes- $39 or 2 dozen mini cupcakes- $39.  

_________________________________________________________________

Gluten Free Options

9” Cake:  Short 9″ serves 6-8, $33-37.  Add $3 for gourmet filling option.   Tall 9″ serves 14-18, $53-57.  Add $5 for gourmet and seasonal filling option.  

1 dozen regular size gluten free cupcakes: $37.  Minimum order 1 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole dozen, but you can choose to have 1/2 of the dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other 1/2 a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet and seasonal fillings, add $2-3 per dozen.  Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor. 

2 dozen mini size gluten free cupcakes: $37.  Minimum order 2 dozen. Cake flavor must be the same for the whole 2 dozen, but you can choose to have 1 dozen one filling and frosting combination, and the other dozen a different filling and frosting combination.  For gourmet and seasonal filling, add $2-3 per dozen.  Marble cake flavor not available as a cupcake flavor.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Scones: These gluten and grain free treats are just that, a treat! Made with almond flour, honey and mini chocolate chips, these are great for anyone who needs a guilt free goodie. Can be made with dairy free chocolate upon request. Minimum order 1 dozen, $14.