Hello there sweet tooth! Thanks for visiting. If you’ve been to our website before, you’ve already noticed it looks a bit different.  We’re working on some updates, changes and new offerings.  You might want to check back often.

Looking to place a custom order?  Click here to view our cake and cupcake menu. 

Have you heard??!  We’re now offering weekly a la carte options available to pick up on Fridays & Saturdays. Click here to check this week’s menu.

We’re now open on Thursdays too!  Beginning on May 28th, we’ll be open:

Thursdays, 12- 6 pm [order cutoff is noon on Tuesday of the same week.]

Fridays, 12-6 pm [order cutoff is noon on Wednesday of the same week.]

Saturdays, 10-2 pm [order cutoff is noon on Thursday of the same week.]

Curbside Pickup!  As our lobby is closed for the time being, all you need to do when you arrive for your scheduled pick up is stay in your vehicle and call 920/893.0617 when you arrive.  We will bring you order up to you and take care of payment then.  

We’ll give you your total when we confirm the order, so you can have a check [payable to Bettersweet Bakery] or cash ready [we will be able to make change if needed].

This is just to protect our own home as well as each other; as there is no way to have several people in our pick up lobby at the same time while maintaining a safe distance from each other. 

Sweets for Others: One of the simplest ways to show love and gratitude for others is through things that bring us comfort. Sweet treats are certainly high on the list of comfort food. Click here to check out our care package options.

Wedding Clients: For all of our potential and current wedding clients, click here for all of our updates specifically for you.