2019 Christmas Menu

Need a quick gift? Invited to a party and all your fruitcake is gone? Are your relatives used to raiding your cookie jar?
Whatever the reason, we have goodies this season!

Stop in anytime we’re open [12/4-12/24] to peruse our lobby full of sweet treats and gifts, packaged to give and enjoy!


Holiday orders can be placed at any time.
online: www.bettersweetbakery.com
email: bettersweetbakery@gmail.com
phone: 920.893.0617
Payment options: cash or check.
Bakery address: N6947 Jennifer Drive Plymouth WI 53073

Any menu item with a * after contains nuts.  

Due to the volume of orders in December, our normal business hours change and we are ONLY able to accommodate pick up appointments during the calendar hours specified. *HOURS ARE LISTED AT THE END OF THIS MENU *

~ Cookies can be ordered as an assortment or individual flavors; i.e. 1 dozen ‘gingerbread trees’. *If you would like to request specific flavors, they must be ordered by the dozen. * Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.
~ You can place a cookie order or just stop in our lobby & pick up one of our gift packaged cookie assortment boxes:
Petite~ 1/2 dozen assorted box, perfect for a simple gift or just a little taste. $5
Deluxe~1.5 dozen assorted box, with a couple of extras of course! $15
Grand~ 2.5 dozen assorted box, a generous amount of cookies, the ultimate gift! $24
~Buy any 10 dozen cookies from This year’s cookie list: get the 11th free PLUS receive a 10% coupon good for your next order!
~Cookies with a * contain nuts. Nut free assortment boxes may be ordered ahead of time. Please request when placing your order.

This year’s cookie list:
Lemon Sandwich Cremes
Chocolate Mint Thumbprints
Caramel Cashew *
Mocha Wreaths
Pistachio dipped Rounds*
Hot cocoa cremes
White Choc. Cranberry Macadamia Nut *
Hazelnut Crescents *
Rum praline buttons *
Cardamom Honey Snowflakes
Ho ho’s sugar crinkles
Gingerbread Trees
Swedish spice delights
Minty swirly spirals
Raspberry Linzer *
Classic Almond Spritz
Dusted Pecan Sandies*
White Chocolate Holiday Trees
Cocoa Crinkles

This year’s collection is a lovely variety of classic, festive & colorful designs. Minimum order 1 dozen, $18. *Gluten free cutouts also available, minimum order 2 dozen, $40.

Thinking of spending some time with your kids or grandkids decorating cutout cookies this season?? What if you didn’t have to bake the cutouts or gather the decorating supplies! Bettersweet has put together the solution in our annual classic sugar cookie kits. This DIY box comes with a generous baker’s dozen of freshly baked cutout cookies, our signature butter frosting, and several small containers of festive sprinkle & sugar decorating choices. Minimum order 1 kit, $15.

Have a lot of sprinkles but just short on time? You can order our signature cutout cookies, without the frosting & décor. Essentially, half of the DIY kit. Minimum order 1 dozen cookies, $10.



We transform our sugar cookies into larger circles and frost them into a whimsical santa face. Incredibly cute and perfect for any stocking or little gift! No minimum order, $2.50 per cookie.

Also known as our ‘plain jane’ macaroons, you’ll love our sweet delicate coconut treats.
Minimum order 1.5 dozen box, $12.

The absolute perfect trio of tea & citrus inspired shortbreads; earl grey, cranberry orange and English breakfast. Unique, yes, but you need to try them! Minimum order 1 dozen box, $8.

The original boys & girls of Christmas town! Approximately 7×5, these old fashioned gingerbread cookies are available in either a simple boy or girl design. Wrapped and ribboned and packaged on a sturdy board… a truly sweet gift. No minimum order, $4 each.

An absolute best seller last year! Our nearly-everyone-famous sammie sandwich cookies are half dipped in rich chocolate, drizzled with a little more chocolate and finished with a touch of edible gold. Minimum order 1 dozen box, $12.

Returning from the cookie vault, these almond shortbread sandwich cookies are filled with bright cherry jam. A festive touch to any cookie plate! Minimum order 1 baker’s dozen box, $12. *



Hand rolled truffles: Smooth, rich and velvety. Our petite 2 piece box is absolutely a chocolate lover’s dream, as well as a perfect little treat! Choose EITHER our
Christmas Eve box: Dark Chocolate & Salted Caramel $3.25/pc. box
Christmas Day box: Grand Mariner [orange] & Coffee $3.25/pc. box

Carole’s Grasshopper Squares: A favorite from our first Christmas season. A rich chocolate base is layered with a delicious minty cream and then enrobed in decadent chocolate ganache. Available as a 6 piece box, $22 or a 1 piece box, $3.75. Renamed for a beloved family member who gave them to everyone on her list 🙂

Peanut Butter Balls: Who doesn’t remember sneaking these in their childhood? Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.

Traditional Rum Rounds: These decadent candies will be a nostalgic addition to your holiday celebration. Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.

Peppermint Stripe Cocoa Squares: New this year! A rich brownie is frosted with a peppermint swirl & dusted with edible sparkle. Minimum order 8 piece box, $9. 


Minimum order 1/2 dozen per flavor, $13
All cupcakes will be decorated with cute holiday sugars and complementing colored sugars.
~ Chocolate w/ cookies n’ crème filling & cookies n’ crème frosting [topped with a handcrafted sammie cookie!]
~ Vanilla bean w/ eggnog crème filling & spiced bourbon butter frosting
~ Chocolate mint w/ mint chip crème filling & chocolate ganche frosting
~ French vanilla white chocolate w/ raspberry cheesecake crème filling & signature butter frosting
~ Gingerbread spice w/ salted caramel vanilla crème & cinnamon cream cheese frosting
~ Red & green vanilla sprinkle w/ vanilla marshmallow crème filling & peppermint butter frosting


New this year! All of our Christmas cakes are available as a single layer 8” cake [serves 6-8] OR a tall 8” cake [serves 12-14]

BLACK FOREST ~ Your celebration centerpiece! This light chocolate cake is filled with a specialty cherry whipped crème and our own slow simmered cherry compote. Finished with chocolate curls and a touch of fudge. 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38.

SANTA CLAUS ~cocoa-mint cake filled with velvety fudge & then frosted with a minty butter cream to image Kris Kringle himself. 8” single heart, $20 or 8? tall heart, $38.

FRESH SNOWFLAKE ~how does a simple triple vanilla cake sound? Delightful indeed. Our french vanilla cake is filled with signature vanilla crème and our bsb’s butter frosting. This frosty white cake is decorated with a icy blue snowflake over the entire top. Finished with edible sparkle and certain to catch your eye. 8” single, $18 or 8? tall, $34.

CHRISTMAS MORNING ~ As bakers, we often get asked our favorite cake flavors. This creation has always been in our top five, and this year we’re sharing it with you! A lovely classic vanilla cake is filled with fresh orange curd crème, topped with our signature chocolate ganache and finished with sliced almonds around the edges. A dusting of dark chocolate cocoa powder and touch of lavish edible gold glitter. * 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38. *

THE DOLLY~ One of the decorator’s favorites! The cake itself is a soft balance of vanilla bean, fresh orange and hints of cranberry. Filled then with a new cranberry orange compote crème and a thin layer of house made orange curd, this stunning centerpiece will leave you speechless! 8” single, $20 or 8? tall, $38.

ALISON’S DREAM~ A lovely coconut cake filled with almond paste sweet crème, frosted with our signature butter cream and covered with both elegant coconut shavings and slivered almonds. 8” single, $18 or 8? tall, $34. *



LEMON RICOTTA LOAF ~ Looking for something light and refreshing? You will find this fresh creation to be a delightful combination of a classic pound cake, lemon flavor, and a lightly sweetened glaze. Loaf cake serves 6-8 guests, $10.
BUCHE DE NOEL~ This fabulous French tradition can be a centerpiece at your celebration. A golden butter sponge cake is filled with EITHER classic chocolate mousse or mocha hazelnut mousse. Rolled into a log with fresh buttercream icing, flaked chocolate and of course, festive edible decorations to make your holiday spirit swoon. $40. 



Handcrafted hot cocoa mix:
~French Vanilla
~Peppermint Stick
~Chocolate Raspberry
$7.50/pint. $3.75/half pint. $13/set of 3 half pints [one of each flavor].
Add a bag of soft, white mini marshmallows, $1/bag.

Spiced Nuts: We use a base of real butter, natural coconut or maple sugar and spice to create our tasty combinations in a healthier version of these holiday classics.
Minimum order 1/2 pound, $8. *
~Rosemary Maple Pecans
~Sea Salted Chai Deluxe Mixed Nuts
~Orange Cinnamon Almonds new this year!



Minimum order: 1 loaf per flavor, $6.75 or 2 mini loaves per flavor, $7 

Eggnog Holiday Pecan *
Cinnamon Apple Streusel
Almond Cherry Poppy Seed*
Triple Chocolate Chip
Orange Cranberry
Blueberry Raspberry



All granola flavors can be created gluten free with a 2 pound minimum [same flavor].

Honey Almond~ A requested favorite that had to be added again this year. Oat flakes, almonds, hazelnuts, honey, coconut sugar, coconut oil, sea salt, vanilla & almond flavorings. Minimum order 1 pound, $8. *

High Five~ The original BSB granola. Oat flakes, wheat flakes, spelt flakes, rye flakes, raw almonds, sunflower seeds, ground flax, honey, agave syrup, olive oil, dried cranberries, dried cherries, cinnamon, & spices. Minimum order 1 pound, $7.50. *

Good Morning~ The seasonal granola! Oat flakes, unsweetened coconut, raw almonds, raw pecans, dried apricots, dried cherries, crystallized ginger, orange zest, coconut milk, honey, sea salt, vanilla & spices. Minimum order 1 pound, $8. *


Perfect for office parties, neighbor goodwill, teacher thank you’s, the foodie in your family or the “I don’t know what to get this person” gift. Built a box with your own selections and we’ll make it look nice! $25 per box.

Here’s what we’ll put in the box:
2 mini loaves tea bread [you pick the flavors]
1 half pint jar of hot cocoa [you pick the flavor]
1 bag of mini marshmallows
1 two piece box of traditional rum balls
1 two piece box of hand rolled truffles [you pick the flavor]
1 petite [1/2 dozen] box of assorted cookies
We’ll add some festive paper shred and extra candies & wrap the whole box up with ribbon and love. 



Cake Pop Truffles~ Flavors may change weekly based upon creative desire. Gift packaged and quite delicious, errr… addictive! Minimum order box of 8, $10.
M’s Eclairs~ A now famous recipe, these oversized chocolate eclairs are so good, you’ll eat them all before dinner. Minimum order 1 dozen, $25.

Memorized M &M Cookies~ He really does have the recipie down pat in this fantastic version of a classic. Minimum order 6 cookies, $3.50.
Reindeer Snack Mix~ A colorful blend of mini animal crackers, white frosted pretzels, chocolate dots, peppermint pretzel balls.. Just to name a few. Minimum order 1 festive bag, $2.50.

Please read through our calendar of available pick up days and times. Remember from 12/4-12/24, our lobby tables will also be stocked with sweet treats and extra goodies!

SUNDAY, 12/1, MONDAY, 12/2 & TUESDAY, 12/3: CLOSED

WEDNESDAY 12/4: 12-7 PM

THURSDAY, 12/5: 12-7 PM

FRIDAY, 12/6: 12-7 PM

SATURDAY, 12/7: 9-3 PM


TUESDAY, 12/10: 12-7 PM

WEDNESDAY, 12/11: 12-7 PM

THURSDAY, 12/12: 12-7 PM

FRIDAY, 12/13: 9-7 PM

SATURDAY, 12/14: 9-3 PM

SUNDAY, 12/15 & MONDAY, 12/16: CLOSED

TUESDAY, 12/17: 12-7 PM

WEDNESDAY, 12/18: 9-7 PM

THURSDAY, 12/19: 9-7 PM

FRIDAY, 12/20: 9-7 PM

SATURDAY, 12/21: 9-7 PM


MONDAY, 12/23: 9-7 PM




FRIDAY, 12/7: 1-6 PM

SATURDAY, 12/28: 9-3 PM

SUNDAY, 12/29,  MONDAY, 12/30 & TUESDAY 12/31: CLOSED

JANUARY HOURS: Note: Bettersweet will be closed for our annual winter break as listed below.

FRIDAY, 1/3: 12-6 PM 

SATURDAY, 1/4: 9-3 PM


FRIDAY, 1/17: 9-6 PM



WEDNESDAY, 1/22: 9-6 PM

THURSDAY, 1/23: 9- 6 PM

FRIDAY, 1/24: 9-6 PM



WEDNESDAY, 1/29: 9-6 PM

THURSDAY, 1/30: 9- 6 PM

FRIDAY, 1/31: 9-6 PM





Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

In the event that you were just asked to bring dessert to Thanksgiving dinner…

Or your turkey is not sharing any oven space, take a peek at our menu and leave the sweetest part of your celebration to us!

Thanksgiving orders will be accepted through Tuesday evening [8 pm], 11/26.

Special menu items are ONLY AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP on Wednesday 11/27 & Thursday 11/28.  

Orders can be placed via email, online or phone, 920/893.0617

Special holiday hours are:
Tuesday 11/26: CLOSED & LAST DAY TO PLACE THANKSGIVING ORDERS!  [Phone calls and emails will be answered throughout the day.]  We will have all extras available in our lobby on both Wednesday and Thursday during open hours.
Wednesday 11/27: 10-7 pm
Thursday 11/28: 8-11 am *THANKSGIVING DAY*
Friday 11/29: CLOSED 
Saturday 11/30: 9-NOON [Thanksgiving menu items not available, only open for other custom order cakes and goodies.]

Stop by Christmas on the Square, a holiday market on Saturday 11/30 from 4-7 pm downtown Elkhart Lake.  We’ll be selling holiday treats, including our Santa Face cookies, hot cocoa jar mixes, grasshopper squares and some surprises!


PIES:  All pies are 9 inch, serving 6-8 guests generously
[only the flavors listed are available this year.  Sorry, no special requests.]

Pumpkin: the classic recipe, $15.
Pumpkin Spice: classic pumpkin with a spiced real cream topping, $17.
Pumpkin Praline: classic pumpkin with a baked on praline crunch topping, $17.
Apple Crumble: crafted with several apple varieties and a buttery brown sugar crumble topping, $16. 
Apple Caramel: apple crumble with caramel baked in and drizzled on top, $17.
Apple Cranberry: apple crumble with fresh seasonal cranberries, $17.
Pecan: the classic recipe, $17.  *contains nuts
Raspberry Custard: a vintage recipe sure to be a little something different for your holiday table, $16.

BREADS:  $6.75 per regular sized loaf, minimum order 1 loaf.  

HOLIDAY ORDERING SPECIAL: 3 pack of mini loaves, 1 of each flavor, $10.

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
Orange Cranberry
Apple Streusel


ORANGE CRANBERRY CHEESECAKE:  fresh tart cranberries are baked into a refreshingly sweet vanilla cheesecake with orange flavor and zest embedded.  A thin layer of our cranberry orange compote completes this unique celebration of two fall flavors, $38.

PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE:  a classic, no nonsense dreamy pumpkin cheesecake with a spiced gingerbread crust, $38.


CARAMEL APPLE BUNDT CAKE:  thinking of something a little different this year?  A wonderfully moist vanilla bundt cake with apples and spice galore!  Dressed up for your holiday meal with a glazing of sweet cream sauce, $28.  * Available in a gluten free version!  $36.

MINI PUMPKIN SHAPED CAKE:  On occasion we make cake that is just cake and frosting, no cream filling.  This particular jem, is just that.  A lovely vanilla cake, shaped like a pumpkin, is frosted in signature butter tinted orange, complete with an edible ‘steam’ and small green vines, $18.  Serves 4-6.  

SIGNATURE CAKES:  Sometimes a two layer cake is just the perfect size, and sometimes you just don’t need that many servings!  So this year, you can order the following cakes in either our traditional two layer 8″ size [serves 12-14 generously] or a single layer 8″ size [serves 6-8 generously].

Carrot: We call it the ‘best ever’, but you might have to try it to decide. * contains walnuts & coconut.  Traditional 2 layer size, $46 or single layer size, $24 

Chicago Holiday:  Golden butter vanilla cake is filled with a creamy pumpkin spiced creme and finished with decadent cream cheese frosting.  *Pumpkin spice cappuccino filling available upon request.  Traditional 2 layer size, $38 or single layer size, $20

Chocolate PB goodness:  rich chocolate cake is complemented by our peanut butter filling and a drizzle of fudge inside.  En robed in chocolate ganache and finished with a simple peanut butter sauce swirl.  *contains peanuts. Traditional 2 layer size, $40 or single layer size, $22 

Our pie inspired mini cupcake box returns by popular request!  Each 1 dozen box of assorted mini cupcakes contains four each of the following three knockout combinations:

Apple pie delight: butter vanilla cupcakes are filled with apple pie creme [apple pie baked without a crust, cooled and folded into our signature vanilla creme] and finished with our cinnamon butter frosting.

Hello, Dolly:   vanilla bean, fresh orange and hints of cranberry cake is filled with a cranberry orange compote creme and finished with our signature butter frosting.

Move over pumpkin: or don’t!  You’re a favorite.  Pumpkin pie spiced vanilla cupcakes are filled with a rich pumpkin creme and finished with a slightly spiced cream cheese frosting.

Minimum order 1 dozen assorted box, $14.


FALLEN LEAVES:  our whimsical assortment of festive shapes and colors will leaf you eating more than one!  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $18.  

GINGERBREAD LEAVES:   the classic Christmas cookie recipe is coming out a few weeks early and finding itself as a leaf instead of a tree.  Delicate white piping will ensure a pretty lovely treat.  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $10.

WHITE CHOCOLATE CRANBERRY COOKIES: A generous baker’s half dozen is packaged up and ready for anyone you might want to gift, maybe even yourself!  Minimum order 1/2 dozen, $5. *Available with roasted, salted macadamia nuts, $7 per half dozen.  

GLUTEN FREE PUMPKIN SCONES: a brand new creation this fall.  We’ve taken our almond flour chocolate chip scone and jazzed it up with fresh pumpkin and just enough spice to have you questioning if you’re going to share.  *Gluten and dairy free. Contains almonds.   Minimum order 1 dozen box, $14.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

what do ghosts eat for dinner?… spooketti. what do ghosts eat for dessert?… bettersweet.

We will be accepting Halloween orders until 6 pm on Tuesday evening, 10/29.  You can email, call or order online.

Special holiday pick up hours will be:

Thursday, 10/31, 8-6 pm [open early for those taking treats to school!]
Friday, 11/1, 9-6 pm
*We will have extra goodies available in our lobby during pick up hours. No guarantees on what or how much we will have, but we always seem some extras.

Now, on to the goodies…

SPIDER OR PUMPKIN CAKE:  A little something from our cauldron this year!  A single layer 8″ cake with your choice of cake flavor, filling flavor, and decoration (all will be frosted with our BSB’s butter frosting).
Cake flavors: french vanilla, classic chocolate, or vanilla sprinkle (w/ black & orange sprinkles).
Filling flavors: raspberry compote w/ vanilla creme, vanilla creme w/ crushed chocolate, or signature vanilla creme.
Decoration: ghost white frosting with a striking black web and edible spiders (we promise they’re cute…not creepy), or pale orange frosting with a ring of butter cream pumpkins around the cake.
[$18 per cake.  Each single layer cake serves 6-8 generously.]

~MONSTER FACE HOMEMADE SAMMIES:  A spooky twist on our homemade chocolate sandwich cookies; we’ve added a bit more festive colored frosting and some edible eyes to look like a friendly little monster peeping out of your cookie. [$10 per box, generous baker’s dozen.  Minimum order 1 box.]

~CHOCOLATE MUMMY BROWNIES:  A fan favorite!  Our 6~chocolate brownies are cut into large circles and frosted to resemble a whimsical mummy face.
[$12 per box of 6, minimum order 1 box.]

~MINI CUPCAKES: These everyone friendly mini cupcakes are decorated for the fun side of Halloween.  Each box includes an assortment of the following three flavors [4 of each flavor] in our MINI cupcake size:
-Vanilla sprinkle w/ (black and orange sprinkles) w/ marshmallow & cookies n’ cream filling, signature butter frosting.
-Classic chocolate w/ caramel chocolate chip creme filling, cocoa butter frosting.
-Butter vanilla w/ apple pie creme filling, cinnamon caramel butter frosting.
[$14 per dozen, minimum order 1 dozen.]

~GHOUL CAKE SLICES: Sometimes we all just need a piece of cake.  Special this year for anyone who simply wants one piece of cake; try a piece of french vanilla cake with four colorful layers [green, purple, orange and black] filled with our signature vanilla cream and colorful butter frosting.  [Minimum order 1 piece, $5.]

~FESTIVE SUGAR COOKIES:  For those of you who have been waiting, you won’t want to miss out!  Our signature cut out cookies are back, in a whimsical variety of cute [never creepy] Halloween colors, characters and designs.  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $18 per box.  


~ABE’S PUMPKIN COOKIES: this year He’ll be rolling out pumpkin shaped sugar cookies decorated to his creative liking.
[$0.50 per cookie, no minimum order.]

~M’s FAMOUS CHOCOLATE ECLAIRS:  She might not be interested in learning to decorate cakes, but this teenage girl can create chocolate eclairs that are good enough to serve to a queen!  From scratch pastries filled with a lovely custard creme and generously drizzled in decadent chocolate.  
[$15 per half dozen, minimum order 1/2 dozen box.]

a few updates for the rest of our fall season, and into winter… but we won’t mention how many weeks until Christmas [yet].

~We are currently asking for a 2 week lead time on all incoming orders. We will always try to accommodate quick orders, but we can not guarantee our availability, especially as the holiday season approaches.
~We will be posting our THANKSGIVING MENU online and sending it out via email the first weekend in November.  All of the details will be there, so if you are thinking ahead [always appreciated], we have you covered.
~Then our CHRISTMAS MENU will be posted and emailed out the day after Thanksgiving [Friday, 11/29].  If you haven’t experienced our Christmas menu in prior years, you are in for a treat… many treats that is.  This is our busiest and most exciting season of the year.  
~Our hours change from Thanksgiving through New Years.  Specific hours during this time will be included with each menu and posted on our website.  These pick up times are firmly set so that we can professionally manage the sheer volume of holiday orders we receive.
~Bettersweet will be closed for our annual winter break from January 5th-16th.  We always like to give everyone an early heads up!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

hop out the the way easter bunny… eggs are for chickens!

Easter orders:

~are available for pick up on Friday 4/19, between 1-6 pm or Saturday 4/20, between 9-3 pm.
~will be accepted until 6 pm on Wednesday 4/17.                                                          ~can be placed online, via email or phone 920/893.0617

  • SPECIAL NOTE!  BETTERSWEET WILL BE CLOSED FROM 4/1 – 4/17. Emails and voicemails will be checked and responded to periodically during that time in regards to orders and Easter specials for 4/19 & 4/20.

Bunnies~ Our best selling cupcake combination, french vanilla w/ raspberry creme filling & BSB’s butter frosting, is adorned with a super cute edible sugar bunny face. Minimum order 1 four piece box, $9.  Also available in 1 dozen increments, $27/dozen

Chicks~ A new creature is joining our menu this year!  Fresh lemon cupcakes are filled with lemon blueberry compote creme, frosted with a cheery yellow buttercream to look like a baby chick.  Minimum order 1 four piece box, $9.  Also available in 1 dozen increments, $27/dozen.

Feeling like you want to try them both?  You can order a box of bunnies & chicks cupcakes together!  Minimum order 1 four piece box, $9.  Also available in 1 dozen increments, $27/dozen.
Egg-citing Mini Cupcakes~ Everyone loves a little cupcake.  Some people love 3, while others love 8.  Whatever number sounds good to you, help yourself to a variety box this holiday season.  We’ve chosen 3 flavors and are offering them as a special assortment.  Available as an assorted  box only [4 of each flavor].  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $14/box.

~Vanilla bean cupcakes w/ blackberry pomegranate crème filling & vanilla bean butter frosting *new flavor!
~Pastel vanilla sprinkle cupcakes w/ marshmallow crème filling & BSB’s signature butter frosting
~Milk chocolate cupcakes w/ fudge cheesecake crème filling & double chocolate cocoa butter frosting

Are you looking for a smaller cake or needing dessert for just a few guests?  Then perhaps one of our single layer cakes would be perfect!   Each of these cakes will serve 6-8 guests.  If you’re looking to serve a few more guests, each of theses cakes can be ordered in our standard 2 layer option, serving 12-14 guests generously.

Springtime Berry~  Our golden butter vanilla cake is layered with a refreshing mixture of mixed berry compote and sweet vanilla crème.  Finished with cream cheese frosting and festive sugar decorations.  Single layer 8″ $18 or a standard 8″, $36.

Easter Egg Wreath Cake~ Vanilla chocolate chip cake is filled with a lovely crushed chocolate cherry compote creme and finished with our almond butter frosting.  Decorated with speckled Cadbury Easter egg candies & pale frosting flowers to look like a festive wreath adorned the top of the cake.  Single layer 8″, $20 or a standard 8″, $40.

Carrot Cake~ This recipe has been perfected over time with distinctive fillings and our own orange essence cream cheese frosting. Single layer 8″, $22 or a standard 8″, $46.

Bird’s Nest Cake~ Back by popular demand! Our milk chocolate cake is baked with tiny chocolate chips, filled with our velvety fudge crème and finished with a layer of light chocolate frosting.  The entire cake is hand piped with small ‘twigs’ and the center is indented slightly, of course to hold room for some pretty speckled chocolate eggs.  Mama bird is perched on top, as you might expect.  Single layer 8″, $20 or a standard 8″, $40.

Bunny Cake~ This staple to our Easter menu will leave your bunny-loving self saying ‘so cute!’ A simple bunny face is decorated in simple, soft colors. $35, serving 12-14 guests.
*Chose one cake flavor and one filling flavor from the following options [all bunny cakes will be frosted with our signature butter frosting]:

Cake flavors:
~French vanilla
~Dark chocolate
~Butter vanilla
~Fresh lemon

Filling flavors:
~Raspberry & vanilla crème
~Cookies n’ cream
~Salted caramel crème
~Lemon curd crème


Lemon Sandwich~ Sometimes we just need a cookie.  Enough said.  Always a best seller during our Christmas holiday, we’ve brought this recipe out of the vault.  Two zesty lemon shortbread cookies filled with lemon cream and topped with a candied lemon wedge and sparkly powdered sugar.  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $10.

Easter Themed Cutouts~Looking to enjoy some of our signature cutout cookies? Well, you don’t have to ask the Easter Bunny to bring you some.  Our assortment of festive Easter cookies will include various shapes and sizes, all decorated with familiar spring time colors!  Minimum order 1 dozen cookies, $18/dozen.  Gluten free cookies available, minimum order 1 dozen, $22.



~ Lemon Swiss Roll~ ordered again and again by those who have tried it!  A light and refreshing lemon sponge cake is filled with a sweet cream, rolled and lightly glazed.  Dusted with candied lemon slices and powdered sugar.  Minimum order 1 cake roll $10.

~ Assorted Cutout Cookies:  Help support our littlest baker as he fine tunes his decorating skills!  Minimum order 6 cookies, $3.

[All sales will go to their ‘save, share and spend’ jars.]



Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

anyone is allowed to be cheesy as Valentine’s Day approaches, and if anyone needs a classic pick up line, here you go: “Do you know first aid? Because Cupid just shot me straight through the heart.”

Valentine’s menu items can be ordered through Wednesday, 2/13 and are available for pick up on:

Wednesday 2/13:  3-6 pm. *special holiday hours*

Thursday, 2/14:  9-6 pm

Friday, 2/15:  9-6 pm

Here’s how to order:

online:  http://bettersweetbakery.com/order-online/

email: bettersweetbakery@gmail.com

phone: 920/893.0617


On to the goodies!


We’d get in trouble if we didn’t put this on our Valentine’s menu.  Our infamous 6-chocolate recipe, frosted rich and delicious.  Perfect for any age, any time.  Minimum order 1 box of 8 heart shaped brownies, $13.


Ever had a deep chocolate lava cake?  Well, have you ever had one of Bettersweet’s?  Special for this time of year, you’ll receive a box of 6 individually portioned lava cakes.  Baked in a free standing fluted cup, these lava cakes are ready for your dessert table.  Simply microwave for 20-30 seconds, add ice cream and splurge.  Instructions will be included.  Unlike most of our custom goodies, these treats are freezer friendly.  Minimum order box of 6, $12/box.


Inspired by the traditional colors for this holiday, we’ve created a box of various sized and colored heart shaped cutout sugar cookies.   You won’t be disappointed with how cute these famous cookies are.  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $18.


Something new this year [that we stole from Christmastime!]  Our famous sammie sandwich cookies are half dipped in decadent chocolate, drizzled with a little more chocolate and finished with a touch of edible gold.  Each box will have 6 white chocolate dipped cookies and 6 dark chocolate dipped cookies; all festively decorated.  Minimum order 1 dozen box, $10.


All cupcakes will be decorated with adorable holiday sugars and sprinkles.  Minimum order 1 dozen mini box, $13.  Each box will have 4 mini cupcakes in the following 3 flavors:

~ Chocolate chocolate chip w/ raspberry cheesecake crème filling & signature butter frosting

~ Vanilla bean w/ pomegranate blackberry compote crème filling & vanilla bean butter  frosting

~ Caramel toffee w/ fudge crème filling & chocolate bourbon butter frosting


This year, we’ve filled our over-sized cupcakes with love [but not bugs].  Minimum order 1 oversized cupcake, $5.  Each cupcake will be individually boxed and decorated, perfect for a little gift!  Choose from either flavor:

Signature red velvet cupcake filled with a semi sweet almond creme, frosted with our cream cheese frosting and finished with crushed European chocolate and edible gold glitter.

Classic chocolate cupcake filled with crushed chocolate creme, frosted with our signature butter and finished with edible hearts.


Looking for a special, but smaller treat to celebrate your valentine?  Why not order a SINGLE layer heart shaped cake in one of four flavors:

french vanilla cake with raspberry and creme filling

chocolate cake with cookies n cream creme filling

strawberry cake with cheesecake creme filling

milk chocolate cake with caramel creme filling

Each flavor combination will be frosted with our signature butter creme frosting.  Your cake will be decorated with soft holiday colors and will say “I love you”.  Different text available upon request.  
Each cake serves approximately 6-8 people.  $17



Need a special gift for a special kid in your world?  Why not something made by a special kid at the bakery!  Abe is gearing up again to make his chocolate dipped pretzels, festively adorned and individually wrapped.  $.75 each or $9 per dozen. No minimum order necessary.


Margo loves to take extra cake and make little sweet cake pops.  Without a stick, she’s named them cake truffles and we’re certain you’d love them too! Minimum order box of 8, $10.  Gift packaged and quite delicious!


Chocolate eclairs so good, you’ll eat them all before dinner. In all seriousness, she could hardly keep up with the requests last December.  Minimum order 1 dozen, $10.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment