The following special Thanksgiving menu items are ONLY AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP on Wednesday 11/27, between 9-5 pm.

Orders can be placed via email or phone, 920/893.0617.  Payment accepted at pick up: cash or check.

Special holiday hours are:

Saturday 11/23: LAST DAY TO PLACE THANKSGIVING ORDERS!  [and view our Christmas menu]

Tuesday 11/26:  CLOSED

Wednesday 11/27: 9-5 pm: Thanksgiving menu items are available.  

Thursday 11/28: CLOSED-HAPPY THANKSGIVING! 

Friday 11/29: CLOSED 

Saturday 11/30: 9-noon, regular menu available. 

Any extra goodies will be available in our lobby during pick up hours on Wednesday.

Now, let’s plan dessert! _____________________________________

CAKES All holiday cakes are an 8″ short size [6-8 servings].

CARAMEL APPLE TOFFEE CRUNCH:  thinking of something a little different this year? Well then, you’re reading the right description.  Our golden vanilla cake has meet a touch of autumnal spices, is filled with both a layer of caramel apple pie toffee crème filling.  Finished with our cream cheese frosting and a generous sprinkling of toffee pieces.  8″ short, $35.

THE CLASSIC: so many of you know our bakery as only one flavor combination, french vanilla cake with raspberry crème filling and signature butter frosting.  Just in case you want to serve this one at your holiday table.  8″ short, $35.

PUMPKIN VANILLA:  A vanilla bean cake layer is filled with pumpkin creme filling and brown butter frosting to make it one fantastic combination. Just enough pumpkin spice to feel like you’re a part of the holiday season at last!  Simple edible fall leaves and a touch of edible gold sparkle decorate this lovely cake.  8″ short, $35.

CHOCOLATE DELIGHT: another classic combination featuring milk chocolate cake with salted caramel vanilla bean crème filling and bourbon butter frosting.  Decorated with a fall colored floral wreath.  8″ short, $35.

MNI CUPCAKES & BRUNCH BREADS

PIE ASSORTMENT: Each dozen box will include 4 each of the following 3 flavors:

~ PUMPKIN: vanilla spice  w/ pumpkin crème filling & cream cheese frosting

~ CHERRY: classic vanilla w/ cherry crème filling & signature butter frosting

~ APPLE:  golden vanilla w/ apple pie compote crème filling & cinnamon butter frosting

Minimum order 1 dozen assorted box, $20.

BRUNCH BREADS: $7.50 per loaf.  Choose from three new flavors!

~ pumpkin mocha ~ cranberry pear streusel ~ harvest [think carrot cake, with apples and walnuts and without frosting!]

HOLIDAY COOKIES, GOODIES & TREATS

ELIZABETH’S FRENCH MACARONS:   we are so excited to partner with this lovely lady again this holiday!  Elizabeth is an extremely talented macaron creator who has come up with some amazingly delicious sounding flavors.  These are naturally gluten free also!

– Box of 6 macarons, $13.  This box includes 2 of each flavor:~ Brown Butter White Chocolate ~ Pumpkin Spice Latte ~ Orange Cranberry

– Box of 12 macarons, $25.  This box includes 3 of each flavor: ~ Brown Butter White Chocolate ~ Pumpkin Spice Latte ~ Orange Cranberry ~ Salted Caramel

BROWN BUTTER PECAN COOKIES: This special recipe is usually available on our wedding dessert menu only.  Incredibly rich and decadent.  If you like butter pecan ANYTHING, you’ll love these!  Minimum order 1 baker’s dozen box, $15.

GLUTEN FREE SCONES: these treats are really more like a soft chocolate chip cookie perfect if you need to avoid gluten.   This holiday, we are adding a touch of maple flavor and some dried cherries to balance out the chocolate. *Contains almonds.   Minimum order 1 baker’s dozen box, $15.  Also available dairy free, $17 per dozen.

GINGERBREAD LEAF COOKIES: Another sweet treat we’ve taken from the recipe vault.  Our gingerbread tree cookie recipe [which you’ll see at Christmas time] is making an appearance as lovely leaves with simple white piping for decoration and touch of gold sparkle.  Minimum order 1 baker’s dozen box, $16.  

ABE’S OFFERINGS

PUMPKIN CAKE ROLL: This not so young anymore kiddo is creating something lovely for Thanksgiving this year and it is as good as it sounds.  Minimum order 1 slice, $4.

GOBBLE GOBBLER COOKIES: Our delicate chocolate sammies are turned into a gobble gobble treat. With these you will no doubt want more $9, per box of 4.    [Abe wrote his own description 🙂  You’ll be receiving 4 hand crafted sammies, which are two softer chocolate cookies filled with our signature butter frosting.  He then adds candy corn to look like turkey feathers, edible sugar eyes and a cute nose.  Such a labor of love!]

It’s not often enough that we say thank you, for the continued support and patronage of our little bakery.  We do not take lightly the honor of being a part of so many celebrations in our community!

Bettersweet has been creating custom order cakes, cupcake orders and special holiday menus for nearly 18 years.  And this year, we find ourselves in uncharted waters as two of our family members are walking though medical challenges and need continued support and care.  While we have been attempting to balance the bakery’s needs with increased care giving over the past several months, we are at a point where the first priority is our family. 

This means, we are shifting to offering only custom order cupcakes at this time.

This change will be effective on September 1^st, 2024.

Here’s a few key bits of information about this change:

~ At the end of August, our cake menu will be taken off of our website and we will be rolling out a new way to order; an order form on our website!  This will allow us to collect all the information needed for your cupcake order, while keeping communication streamlined and efficient, as time has become more precious than ever before.

~ We will continue to offer our full wedding services [including cakes, cupcakes and petite desserts]. 

~ For the time being, we will continue to offer our a la carte menus via Facebook.

~ We’re not sure what this holiday season will look like, but we’ll let you know as our plans are settled. 

~ We will be offering extra large cupcakes, a size that is perfect for you to add to your cupcake order and gift/serve to whomever you are celebrating.  

Thank you for supporting us.

Thank you for reaching out to other local bakeries if your celebration simply just calls for a cake. 

And thank you, for understanding. 

The Bettersweet Family: Curt, Jen, Margo & Abe. 

We have plenty of goodies for a little something to tangibly tell your mom, anyone who has been like a mom or your kid’s mom- how much you appreciate them.   

Picking up your order:

Saturday, 5/11 between between 10-4 pm.  Please note, only items from our special Mother’s Day menu are available to pick up on 5/11.

Placing your order:

Can be done via email, or giving us a call at 920/893.0617.  Please denote your requested pick up time and please provide a contact phone number for your order. 
We do reply to every email and voicemail we receive!  If you don’t hear back from us in 2-3 business days, please contact us to make sure we received your order.  Order deadline is Wednesday 5/8 at 8 pm.

Paying for your order:

We accept cash or check for payment.

______________________________________________________________

On to the sweets!
Please note, the following Mother’s Day menu items will be available ONLY on Saturday 5/11.

Cakes! Enjoy a small cake or try a few different flavors!  Each of the following cakes comes in a 6″ single layer size, serving 2-3 generously.  

~ Razmon Delight:  one of our most popular signature cake starts with a raspberry vanilla batter, is filled with mascarpone lemon creme and finished with a touch of raspberry infused cream cheese frosting.  $24.   

~Peanut Square: this classic vanilla cake is filled with vanilla creme filling and frosted with our signature butter and then completely covered in freshly ground, salted Spanish peanuts. $24.  

~ Chocolate Coffee: this one is a hidden favorite on our menu! Milk chocolate cake with chocolate raspberry cappuccino creme filling and mocha butter frosting.  $22.

~ The Classic: what else could this be but french vanilla cake with raspberry compote creme filling and our signature butter frosting.  $22.

~ Cherry & Chocolate:  if you’ve had this filling, then you know why this flavor is on our menu.  Vanilla chocolate chip cake with crushed white chocolate cherry creme filling and bourbon butter frosting.  $24.

~ GLUTEN FREE, The Classic, but made gluten free!  $24.

Cupcakes!  We’ve brought 3 fruity cupcake flavors out of the recipe vault this year.  You also have the option to order this regular size cupcake assortment as either a half dozen box or dozen box.  The half dozen [$18] will have 2 of each flavor and the full dozen [$36] will have 4 of each flavor combination:

~ vanilla bean cupcake with strawberry rhubarb creme filling & brown butter frosting

~ fresh orange cupcake with white chocolate lavender creme filling & cream cheese frosting

~ coconut blueberry cupcake with lime curd creme filling & vanilla bean butter frosting

Treats!

French Macarons: From Elizabeth @ Cedar Springs Floral Co- “Mother’s Day is just around the corner, and I have had so much fun putting together this year’s macaron box! Butterflies + florals + pastels make for a beautiful spring themed box that is perfect for all the moms we know! ??”

Due to their size, the butterfly macarons pictured will only be featured in the boxes of 12, however the floral macarons will still be included in the boxes of 6.  Head to our Facebook page to see a photo of these incredible cookies.  

Here are the flavors and details:
•Key Lime
•White Chocolate Raspberry Rose
•Lemon Poppy seed
•Brown Butter Milk Chocolate (the butterfly shape- only available in the boxes of 12)

•Box of 6 macarons for $13- contains 2 each of Key Lime, White Chocolate Raspberry Rose, and Lemon Poppy seed

•Box of 12 macarons for $25- contains 3 each of Key Lime, White Chocolate Raspberry Rose, Lemon Poppy seed, and Brown Butter Milk Chocolate

Lemon Sandwich Cookies:  These little gems have been a favorite for almost 17 years here at the bakery.  We traditionally only let them out at Christmas time but after their standing ovation on our Easter menu, here we go again.  Two lemon shortbread cookies are sandwiched with a zesty lemon creme filling and finished with a candied lemon piece. Refreshing and addicting.  $15, 1 generous baker’s dozen box.  

Abe’s Menu!

Heart Brownies: Our multi-chocolate recipe is cut out into hearts and decorated per Abe’s love for all things bakery!  $10 per box of 4 brownies.  

Cake Slice: vanilla cake tinted light pink with crushed chocolate creme filling and vanilla bean butter frosting.  Decorated with pretty sugar flowers and Abe’s creative touches.  $4 per slice.  

Easter orders:

~are available for pick up ONLY on Saturday 3/30, between 10-4 pm. 
~will be accepted until 8 pm on Thursday, 3/28.                                                              ~can be placed via email [jen@bettersweetbakery.com] or phone 920/893.0617

Please note~ if you’re looking for a custom cake or cupcake order, that can be placed for pick up on Friday, 3/29 from 12-6 pm.  We will be limiting the amount of custom orders we accept that weekend, to make room for all the festive goodies below!  

_____________________________________________________________

Egg-citing Mini Cupcakes~ 

Everyone loves a little cupcake.  Some people love 3, while others love 8.  Whatever number sounds good to you, help yourself to two different variety boxes this holiday season.  

Hop To It box: Available as an assorted box only [4 of each flavor] of festively decorated treats.  $18/box.

~Golden vanilla w/ blueberry creme filling & vanilla bean butter frosting 
~Pastel vanilla sprinkle  w/ marshmallow crème filling & BSB’s signature butter frosting
~French vanilla w/ raspberry crème filling & signature butter frosting

Some Bunny box: Available as an assorted box only [4 of each flavor] of festively decorated treats.  $18/box.

~Milk chocolate w/ double chocolate fudge creme filling & cookies n’ cream butter frosting 
~Classic chocolate w/ crushed chocolate creme filling & signature butter frosting
~Vanilla chocolate chip w/ salted caramel & cocoa butter frosting

Spring Cakes~
Each of the cake flavors below are available in our short 8? size.  If you need more than the 6-8 servings that a short 8? size allows- order a second cake.  Who knows, you might stumble upon a new family favorite.  

The Best Ever Carrot Cake~ It’s been a few years since we’ve highlighted this now 17 year old recipe.  Our version of this classic has walnuts, pineapple and coconut and plenty of rich cream cheese frosting to round off your celebration.  8″short-$36.  

Bird’s Nest Cake~ An Easter favorite! Milk chocolate cake is baked with tiny chocolate chips, filled with our velvety fudge crème and finished with a layer of light chocolate frosting.  The entire cake is hand piped with small ‘twigs’ and the center is indented slightly, of course to hold room for some pretty speckled chocolate eggs.  Mama bird is perched on top, as you might expect. 8? short-$34.

Bunny Face~ Our most requested combination ever, that we think it can appear on every holiday menu.  Light and airy French vanilla cake is filled with raspberry compote layered with vanilla creme filling and finished with our signature butter frosting.  It will be simply frosted in a pretty pale color with a whimsical bunny face on top!  8? short-$34.

Maple Cardamom Dream Cake~ Our newest creation! Fragrant spices are infused into a golden vanilla cake.  Filled with a cinnamon sugar creme and finished with our maple butter cream.  Decorated with lovely pastel spring flowers.  8″ short-$34.  

Brunch Bread~ Our sweet breads are absolutely perfect for your Easter weekend brunch,  a small gift for a neighbor or a thoughtful hostess gift.  We even have a brand new flavor for you to try!  $7.50 per loaf.  

Cherry Almond Poppy Seed [contains almonds]

Raspberry White Chocolate

Blackberry Lemon Sage

Sweet Treats~

Lemon Sandwich Cookies~ Sometimes we just need a cookie.  Enough said.  Always a best seller during our Christmas holiday, we’ve brought this recipe out of the vault.  Two zesty lemon shortbread cookies filled with lemon cream and topped with a candied lemon wedge and sparkly powdered sugar.  $15 per baker’s dozen box.

Monster Cookies, Easter Edition~ Margo is sneaking this recipe from the vault and creating one of our fan favorite cookies.  Filled with oats, peanut butter, chocolate chips, peanuts, pastel M&M™ candies,  $8 per baker’s half dozen.  [contains peanuts]

Easter Egg Brownies~  Abe is also taking one of our favorite recipes and adding a holiday twist.  Our well known chocolate brownies are egg shaped and frosted in different pastel colors.  $7 per box of 4.