What does the gingerbread man put on his bed??? A cookie sheet. (now stop giggling and order some cookies!)

~Holiday orders will be accepted beginning on Monday 11/24/15.

~We appreciate & suggest orders be placed at least one week in advance.

~Orders may be placed:

online: http://bettersweetbakery.com/order-online/

email: bettersweetbakery@gmail.com 

phone: 920.893.0617

~Due to the volume of orders during our holiday season, our normal business hours change and we are ONLY able to accommodate pick up appointments during the calendar hours specified. VISIT THE CALENDAR HERE: http://bettersweetbakery.com/order-online/

~Payment options:   cash or check

~All orders will include an additional  box & packaging fee.  This varies based on the size and specifics of your order.

~Not certain what your guests might enjoy?  Let us help!

~Gift certificates are available… in any amount!

Beginning on Thursday, 12/3, our lobby tables will be filled with items available for walk in purchase.  Choose from pre-boxed cookie assortments, hot cocoa assortments, teacher gifts, jar mixes and of course, extra treats!  This holds for any and all of our holiday hours through 12/31.

Any item with a * contains nuts. Any other specific ingredient concerns? Please ask when ordering.

Signature Truffles

  • Handcrafted from the finest quality ingredients.
  • Minimum order 1 dozen. $17/dozen.
  • Order two 6 pc boxes [1 of each flavor] or one 12 pc box [2 of each flavor]
  • Includes holiday ribbon packaging… ready for gift giving!

Dark Chocolate ~ Salted Caramel~ Eggnog

Raspberry Cheesecake ~ Coffee ~ Pomegranate

Holiday Breads

  •  Perfect for brunch or gift giving!
  • Minimum order 2 loaves per flavor.  $6.50/loaf

Eggnog Holiday *

Blueberry Raspberry Cream


Lemon Poppy Seed

Cherry Almond Pistachio *

Orange Cranberry

Festive Cupcakes

  • Minimum order 1 dozen.  Either 1 dozen per variety for 1 dozen of either assortment [will include 4 of each 3 flavors]. $25/dozen.
  • All cupcakes will be decorated with cute holiday sugars and complementing colored sugars.
  • All of the following cupcakes can be ordered in a gluten free version! $28/dozen [minimum order 1 dozen per flavor on gluten free]

Sleigh Bell Box [kid friendly]

~ Classic vanilla w/ hot cocoa crème & peppermint BSB’s butter frosting

~ Fun-illa fetti w/ signature vanilla crème & BSB’s butter frosting

~ Milk chocolate w/ mint cookies and crème & BSB’s butter frosting

Holly & Ivy Box [adult flavors]

~ Amaretto w/ eggnog crème & spiced butter frosting

~ Milk chocolate stout w/ irish crème & whisky bourbon butter frosting

~ Vanilla bean w/ raspberry cheesecake & cream cheese frosting

Holiday Cakes

Santa Claus ~cocoa-mint cake filled with velvety fudge & then frosted with a minty butter cream to image Kris Kringle himself. $34

The Dolly ~this one is fantastic:  The cake itself is a soft balance of vanilla bean, fresh orange and hints of cranberry.  Filled then with a cranberry orange compote crème and a thin layer of house made orange curd… you won’t be able to speak while trying this stunning centerpiece! $34.

Eggnog Layer ~a simply elegant cake: layers of a modern gingerbread cake are filled with eggnog & brandy infused crème, frosted with a stunning white butter cream.  Tiny snowflakes and fresh grated nutmeg adorn the top. $32.

Simple Snowman ~just in time for the holidays!  We’ve created a single layer cake, fun-illa cake (red & green sprinkles in our french vanilla cake) filled with a thin layer of signature vanilla crème and decorated in a whimsical snowman face, hat and scarf to boot! $20.

Buche De Noel ~the fabulous French tradition comes alive here in Wisconsin.  A golden butter sponge cake is filled with EITHER classic chocolate mousse or mocha hazelnut mousse.  Rolled into a log with fresh buttercream icing, flaked chocolate and of course, festive edible decorations to make our holiday spirit swoon.  $40.

Signature Sugar Cookie Cutouts

~ A collection of classic and artistic holiday designs.   Minimum order 1 dozen  $16/dozen.

Do It Yourself Box~ What could be better than spending the afternoon with your kids or grandkids decorating cutout cookies…. probably if you didn’t have to bake the cutouts or gather the decorating supplies!  Bettersweet has put together the solution in our sugar cookie kits.  This DIY box comes with a baker’s dozen freshly baked cutout cookies, our signature butter frosting, and several small containers of festive sprinkle choices.   Minimum order 1 dozen box $15.

M’s Menu~ Our little baker in training, Margo or ‘M’, has been gearing up for Christmas since July.  Here’s what she has to offer:  [All sales will go to her ‘save, share and spend’ jars.]

~ Snowman cutouts: These super cute snowmen will have your heart in a moment! And then you can eat them. Minimum order box of 6, $5.

~ Green heart cookies: A little edible take on the famous Grinch story.  Minimum order 1 dozen cookies, $6 per dozen.

~ Snowy Day snack mix: If you nibble, or know someone who does, you’ll understand why this salty sweet snack mix will become a quick favorite.  Will be available in grab and go size bags in the lobby, no minimum order needed. $2.50/bag

Cookie Information

~This year we’re looking at cookies just a little differently.  We will no longer have our flavors divided into categories, but rather offer you the choice to purchase them as:

* Single flavors: i.e. 1 dozen gingerbread trees

* Baker’s choice assortment: just tell us how many dozen you would like

* Nut free assortment

* Kid friendly assortment

~All cookies will be $10/dozen

~Buy any 10 dozen cookies: get the 11th free PLUS receive a 10% coupon good for your next order!

~Need a quick gift? You can pre-order our cookie assortment boxes.

* Petite1/2 dozen box, perfect for an add on gift or a little taste.  $5

* Deluxe1.5 dozen box, with a couple extras of course! $15

* Grand2.5 dozen box, a generous amount of cookies, the ultimate gift!  $24


This Year’s Cookie List

  1. Lemon Sandwich
  2. Spritz
  3. Chocolate Mint Thumbprints
  4. Caramel Cashew *
  5. Pistachio Dipped Shortbread *
  6. Mocha Wreaths
  7. Minty Polka-Dot Trees
  8. North Pole M&M
  9. White Chocolate w/ Cranberry & Macadamia Nuts *
  10. Rainbow Surprise
  11. Earl Grey
  12. Grapefruit Sandwich
  13. Coconut Hearts *
  14. Gingerbread Trees
  15. Espresso Cups
  16. White Chocolate Holiday Trees
  17. Hazelnut Crescents *
  18. Rum Praline Shortbread *
  19. Raspberry Linzer *
  20. Velvet Crinkles
  21. Salted PB Chip *
  22. Cardamom Honey Snowflakes

Any item with a * contains nuts. Any other specific ingredient concerns? Please ask when ordering.

Need something special this season? Give or send one of our gift boxes!

  • Nestled in our beautiful holiday boxes [ready for you to ship as well], you will find some of the finest of what Bettersweet offers.
  • You chose the size and the flavors you would like to include.
  • Each box will include a handful of festive holiday candies, on us!

Medium Box Includes: $30
1 loaf of bread OR 1 jar of hot cocoa mix
1 lb granola OR 6 pc truffles [holiday assortment box]
1.5 dozen assorted cookies

Large Box Includes: $45
2 loaves of bread OR 1 loaf and 1 jar of hot cocoa mix
1 lb granola OR 6 pc truffles [holiday assortment box]
2.5 dozen assorted cookies

Jar Mixes~ Why not pick up that foodie on your list a special stocking stuffer?  Packaged in glass mason jars with festive labeling, ribbon and easy to follow instructions.

  • Hot cocoa: a classic cocoa flavor with just enough sweetness!  Available in French Vanilla, Peppermint Mocha, or Caramel Toffee. $7/pint.  $3.50/half pint.  $12/ set of 3 half pints.  Add a bag of soft, white mini marshmallows, $1/bag.
  • Santa’s Supreme Cookies: these will certainly make everyone’s favorite list, toasted coconut, chocolate chunks, cashews, white chocolate and holiday M&M’s…. Whew! * $10/quart jar.
  • Peppermint Cocoa Cookies: simple and delicious.  $10/quart jar.
  • Triple Chocolate Toffee Cookies: crunchy toffee pairs up with cocoa, white chocolate, and milk chocolate.  Who doesn’t need a triple dose of chocolate?  $10/quart jar.
  • ‘Those’ Chocolate Chip Scones: hello gluten free magic!  You’ll never know these goodies are actually healthy!  Made with an almond flour base. * $10/quart jar.

Grasshopper Squares~ cake like brownie bottom, a creamy minty essence filling and a smooth, rich ganache covering.   Unbelievable!  Minimum order ½ dozen. $20 half dozen.


  • High Five: ingredients: oat flakes, wheat flakes, spelt flakes, rye flakes, raw almonds, sunflower seeds, ground flax, honey, agave syrup, olive oil, dried cranberries, dried cherries, cinnamon, & spices.  Minimum order 1 pound. $7/pound
  • Festivus~ ingredients: oat flakes, wheat flakes, kamut flakes, raw pecans, ground flax, honey, agave syrup, olive oil, dried cranberries, dried cherries, dried apples, cinnamon, cloves & nutmeg.  Minimum order 1 pound. $7/pound.
  • Turkey Day~ ingredients: oat flakes, pecans, pepitas, raw sugar, sea salt, pumpkin puree, olive oil, maple syrup, maple sugar & spices. $7/pound.
  •  Good Morning~ ingredients: gluten free oat flakes, unsweetened coconut, raw almonds, raw pecans, dried apricots, dried cherries, crystalized ginger, orange zest, coconut milk, honey, sea salt, vanilla & spices. Minimum order 1 pound. $8.50/pound.

Gluten Free Goodness~ BSB is always trying to accommodate sensitivities and allergies.  Here’s what we have to offer this year.  Please email or call for more information.

~ Cookie assortment: we are still finalizing the flavors for this gluten free cookie box.  Advance ordering suggested.  * $15/dozen

~ Cherry chocolate macaroons:  unbelievable!  These gluten free and diabetic friendly cookies are a really special treat.  $10/dozen

~ Chocolate chip scones:  moist and delicious!  These simple gluten and grain free treats are just that, a treat!  Embedded with mini chocolate chips and a sweet vanilla flavor.  * $14/dozen

~ Cherry cheesecake:  our gluten free New York style cheesecake is topped with a cheerful layer of cherry compote.  You won’t know it’s anything but good!  * $48


~Orders may be placed:

online: http://bettersweetbakery.com/order-online/

email: http://bettersweetbakery.com/contact/email-us/

phone: 920.893.0617

~ Due to the volume of orders during our holiday season, our normal business hours change and we are ONLY able to accommodate pick up appointments during the hours specified below.

Saturday 12/5 9-3pm

Sunday & Monday 12/6 & 12/7 CLOSED

Tuesday 12/8 2-7pm

Wednesday 12/9 CLOSED

Thursday 12/10 2-7pm

Friday 12/11 2-7pm

Saturday 12/12 9-3pm

Sunday & Monday 12/13 & 12/14 CLOSED

Tuesday 12/15 2-7pm

Wednesday 12/16 2-7pm

Thursday 12/17 2-7pm

Friday 12/18 9-7pm

Saturday 12/19 9-3pm

Sunday 12/20 CLOSED

Monday 12/21 9-7pm

Tuesday 12/22 9-7pm

Wednesday 12/23 9-7pm

Thursday 12/24 *CHRISTMAS EVE* 8-11am

Friday 12/25 CLOSED

Saturday -Monday 12/26 – 12/28 CLOSED

Tuesday 12/29 2-7pm

Wednesday 12/30 2-7pm

Thursday 12/31 9-noon

January 1-15 CLOSED *Annual Winter Break*

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.