Or your turkey is not sharing any oven space, take a peek at our menu and leave the sweetest part of your celebration to us!
Thanksgiving orders will be accepted through Tuesday evening [8 pm], 11/26.
Special menu items are ONLY AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP on Wednesday 11/27 & Thursday 11/28.
Orders can be placed via email, online or phone, 920/893.0617
Special holiday hours are:
Tuesday 11/26: CLOSED & LAST DAY TO PLACE THANKSGIVING ORDERS! [Phone calls and emails will be answered throughout the day.] We will have all extras available in our lobby on both Wednesday and Thursday during open hours.
Wednesday 11/27: 10-7 pm
Thursday 11/28: 8-11 am *THANKSGIVING DAY*
Friday 11/29: CLOSED
Saturday 11/30: 9-NOON [Thanksgiving menu items not available, only open for other custom order cakes and goodies.]
MARK YOUR CALENDAR!
Stop by Christmas on the Square, a holiday market on Saturday 11/30 from 4-7 pm downtown Elkhart Lake. We’ll be selling holiday treats, including our Santa Face cookies, hot cocoa jar mixes, grasshopper squares and some surprises!
ON TO THE THANKSGIVING GOODIES….
PIES: All pies are 9 inch, serving 6-8 guests generously
[only the flavors listed are available this year. Sorry, no special requests.]
Pumpkin: the classic recipe, $15.
Pumpkin Spice: classic pumpkin with a spiced real cream topping, $17.
Pumpkin Praline: classic pumpkin with a baked on praline crunch topping, $17.
Apple Crumble: crafted with several apple varieties and a buttery brown sugar crumble topping, $16.
Apple Caramel: apple crumble with caramel baked in and drizzled on top, $17.
Apple Cranberry: apple crumble with fresh seasonal cranberries, $17.
Pecan: the classic recipe, $17. *contains nuts
Raspberry Custard: a vintage recipe sure to be a little something different for your holiday table, $16.
BREADS: $6.75 per regular sized loaf, minimum order 1 loaf.
HOLIDAY ORDERING SPECIAL: 3 pack of mini loaves, 1 of each flavor, $10.
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
Orange Cranberry
Apple Streusel
HOLIDAY TREATS: CHEESECAKES
ORANGE CRANBERRY CHEESECAKE: fresh tart cranberries are baked into a refreshingly sweet vanilla cheesecake with orange flavor and zest embedded. A thin layer of our cranberry orange compote completes this unique celebration of two fall flavors, $38.
PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE: a classic, no nonsense dreamy pumpkin cheesecake with a spiced gingerbread crust, $38.
HOLIDAY TREATS: CAKES
CARAMEL APPLE BUNDT CAKE: thinking of something a little different this year? A wonderfully moist vanilla bundt cake with apples and spice galore! Dressed up for your holiday meal with a glazing of sweet cream sauce, $28. * Available in a gluten free version! $36.
MINI PUMPKIN SHAPED CAKE: On occasion we make cake that is just cake and frosting, no cream filling. This particular jem, is just that. A lovely vanilla cake, shaped like a pumpkin, is frosted in signature butter tinted orange, complete with an edible ‘steam’ and small green vines, $18. Serves 4-6.
SIGNATURE CAKES: Sometimes a two layer cake is just the perfect size, and sometimes you just don’t need that many servings! So this year, you can order the following cakes in either our traditional two layer 8″ size [serves 12-14 generously] or a single layer 8″ size [serves 6-8 generously].
Carrot: We call it the ‘best ever’, but you might have to try it to decide. * contains walnuts & coconut. Traditional 2 layer size, $46 or single layer size, $24
Chicago Holiday: Golden butter vanilla cake is filled with a creamy pumpkin spiced creme and finished with decadent cream cheese frosting. *Pumpkin spice cappuccino filling available upon request. Traditional 2 layer size, $38 or single layer size, $20
Chocolate PB goodness: rich chocolate cake is complemented by our peanut butter filling and a drizzle of fudge inside. En robed in chocolate ganache and finished with a simple peanut butter sauce swirl. *contains peanuts. Traditional 2 layer size, $40 or single layer size, $22
HOLIDAY TREATS: CUPCAKES
Our pie inspired mini cupcake box returns by popular request! Each 1 dozen box of assorted mini cupcakes contains four each of the following three knockout combinations:
Apple pie delight: butter vanilla cupcakes are filled with apple pie creme [apple pie baked without a crust, cooled and folded into our signature vanilla creme] and finished with our cinnamon butter frosting.
Hello, Dolly: vanilla bean, fresh orange and hints of cranberry cake is filled with a cranberry orange compote creme and finished with our signature butter frosting.
Move over pumpkin: or don’t! You’re a favorite. Pumpkin pie spiced vanilla cupcakes are filled with a rich pumpkin creme and finished with a slightly spiced cream cheese frosting.
Minimum order 1 dozen assorted box, $14.
HOLIDAY TREATS: COOKIES
FALLEN LEAVES: our whimsical assortment of festive shapes and colors will leaf you eating more than one! Minimum order 1 dozen box, $18.
GINGERBREAD LEAVES: the classic Christmas cookie recipe is coming out a few weeks early and finding itself as a leaf instead of a tree. Delicate white piping will ensure a pretty lovely treat. Minimum order 1 dozen box, $10.
WHITE CHOCOLATE CRANBERRY COOKIES: A generous baker’s half dozen is packaged up and ready for anyone you might want to gift, maybe even yourself! Minimum order 1/2 dozen, $5. *Available with roasted, salted macadamia nuts, $7 per half dozen.
GLUTEN FREE PUMPKIN SCONES: a brand new creation this fall. We’ve taken our almond flour chocolate chip scone and jazzed it up with fresh pumpkin and just enough spice to have you questioning if you’re going to share. *Gluten and dairy free. Contains almonds. Minimum order 1 dozen box, $14.